• 10 months ago
Stefan Molyneux examines a parenting situation with Jeremy Kauffman and his son, focusing on a dispute about a dropped carrot. He points out how this reflects aspects of child development, such as finding a balance between obedience and independence, especially in boys. He notes that children's actions often echo their parents' and suggests avoiding rigid responses to pushback. Molyneux highlights curiosity in parenting as a way to grasp what drives children, which can help build connections and improve dialogue, while prompting a fresh look at typical discipline practices.

The tweet: https://x.com/StefanMolyneux/status/2010730504656658607

GET FREEDOMAIN MERCH! https://shop.freedomain.com/

SUBSCRIBE TO ME ON X! https://x.com/StefanMolyneux

Follow me on Youtube! https://www.youtube.com/@freedomain1

GET MY NEW BOOK 'PEACEFUL PARENTING', THE INTERACTIVE PEACEFUL PARENTING AI, AND THE FULL AUDIOBOOK!
https://peacefulparenting.com/

Join the PREMIUM philosophy community on the web for free!

Subscribers get 12 HOURS on the "Truth About the French Revolution," multiple interactive multi-lingual philosophy AIs trained on thousands of hours of my material - as well as AIs for Real-Time Relationships, Bitcoin, Peaceful Parenting, and Call-In Shows!

You also receive private livestreams, HUNDREDS of exclusive premium shows, early release podcasts, the 22 Part History of Philosophers series and much more!

See you soon!
https://freedomain.locals.com/support/promo/UPB2025
Transcript
00:00All right. Hi, everybody. Stephen Molyneux from Freedom, Maine. Hope you're doing well.
00:04So, Jeremy Kaufman, I think I interviewed him once, and Jeremy Kaufman wrote, this went pretty
00:14viral, wrote fairly recently, when one of my children was two, he dropped a carrot on the
00:20floor and refused to pick it up. He was told he would not be allowed to do anything fun or have
00:25any privileges until he picked up the carrot. He refused for hours. He cried and screamed. He even
00:31napped, woke up and continued to refuse. His commitment was impressive. We held fast until
00:37he picked up the carrot. He would receive nothing other than water and basic food to live. After over
00:43four hours, he picked up the carrot and apologized. It's the longest he's fought us to this day.
00:49Disobedience is a choice of parents who get the behavior that you tolerate.
00:55This was his. He's a free state project guy. So, he's a free state libertarian.
01:04So, I'm sure that we would have a lot in common, perhaps not so much, with regards to this
01:11approach to parenting. So, let's break it down. And we will also get into, hopefully, if we have time,
01:19we will get into the philosophy of why people confess to priests and so on, right? So, let's,
01:28let's get into it. So, what does this mean, this idea that you have this sort of battle of wills
01:37with your two-year-old, right? That's a, that's a pretty wild thing to me.
01:43Okay. So, a two-year-old. Now, it's funny because two-year-old could be early two or late two. In
01:51other words, the two could be half of your life or a third of your life. So, we'll just say two,
01:58two and a half or something like that, right? But it's a pretty wild thing because, for me,
02:05the important part is to be curious about what's going on. Why would a two-year-old not want to pick
02:15up a piece of carrot, right? So, children are hardwired to want to obey their parents.
02:24That is absolute basic Darwinian survival, right? So, if a child is running and a parent says stop,
02:31then the child will stop in general. I mean, they're wired that way because suppose they're
02:37running towards some secret hole in the ground, suppose they're running towards there's a snake
02:42there or a predator or it's a cliff edge or, or something. So, children are hardwired to do what
02:50their parents say. I remember once with my daughter, she was jumping and I can't remember why there was
02:58something risky she was doing by a pool and I said stop and she kind of stopped and half-faulted
03:03and it was like automatic, like my language caused her to stop because that's how children are
03:10hardwired. It wasn't any punishment, right? I've never punished my daughter. So, children, I know that's
03:16just one example, but we can understand it from an evolutionary standpoint that children that defied
03:22their parents, right? So, the parent knows that the red berries are poisonous and the child has a
03:27fistful of red berries, it's going to the mouth, the parent says stop, then the children who don't
03:33listen to that die or get sick or, you know, have some sort of negative, negative outcome, right?
03:40If there's an animal that the kid thinks is cute but it's actually dangerous and the kid wants to pet it
03:45and the parent says stop, the kid who doesn't listen is less likely to survive the encounter,
03:51right? So, children want to obey their parents and they're hardwired to do so. So, what is it that
04:01interferes with that? Well, children have, particularly boys, they have dual impulses. Now, people can say,
04:08ah, but Steph, you have but a daughter. And that is true. I have but a daughter. However, I was a boy
04:16and I was friends with boys and I worked in a daycare for years where there were lots of, yes, that's
04:23right, boys. So, hopefully this will make sense. I'll deal with some experience, but I'll also give
04:30you the reasoning behind it. Hopefully this makes sense. So, boys and girls, I'm just going to talk
04:37about boys because this is a boy situation here. So, boys want to obey their parents. However,
04:46the problem is that if boys only obey their parents, then the boys don't learn to think for themselves,
04:54challenge authority, become their own people, and thus become attractive to females. Quality women
05:01do not want a boy who is a slave to his parents, who just does whatever his parents want and obeys
05:09their parents and never thinks for themselves and never challenges any kind of authority and never
05:15steps outside of the box of conformity, right? So, boys have a dual impulse in that they want,
05:25and just think of the genetics, right? Why is the boy saying, no, I don't want to pick up a carrot?
05:31So, boys need to go up in the hierarchy to get the most quality females, right? This is why boys have
05:40all this testosterone and ambition and tend to be less conformist and, you know, score lower on trait
05:46agreeableness and so on, why we are difficult, why we are exasperating to female teachers and mothers
05:54and aunts and like, well, why don't you just do what your father says. So, in order for boys to be
06:01attractive, we are hardwired to climb the hierarchy. And climbing the hierarchy means displacing the males
06:08above us. It means aggressively, assertively, however you want to do it, we have to displace
06:16the males above us. So, to sort of take a typical example from the hunter-gatherer societies,
06:22in hunter-gatherer societies, the best hunter gets the best girl, right? The best hunter gets the best
06:29woman. Let's just, I mean, simplify it. I know there's more than that, but let's just say. So, the best hunter
06:33gets the best girl. Now, when you're a kid, there is already a best hunter who does not want to lose
06:39his status. However, to get the best girl, you have to challenge and overthrow the best male. I don't
06:47mean physical combat, although it could be that, but you have to challenge and overthrow the alpha male
06:53in order to become the alpha male. And all boys have this duality that they want to please their
07:00parents, and they are also hardwired to defy their fathers, in particular. Of course. Because,
07:10again, if he doesn't defy his father, he cannot rise to the top of the hierarchy and get the best
07:16girl. And what you have, I think, what you have going on here between Jeremy Kaufman and his son
07:24is Jeremy wishes to stay at the top of the hierarchy, but his son has a deep resistance
07:32to the male who's at the top of the hierarchy because the son knows that to get them, or genetically
07:39kind of gets, the instinct has evolved, that in order to get the highest quality woman, he has to
07:45overthrow the dominant male in the environment. So, he will not just take orders. And Jeremy, of course,
07:55is funny because he's a, I think he's a libertarian, and as a libertarian or as somebody who wants a
08:01smaller government or a skeptical of political power, he also wants, in a sense, to diminish or
08:08overthrow the alpha politicians in the environment, right? So, what's happening is a hierarchy
08:18combat. If Jeremy's son does not resist and overthrow a dominant male, which he's practicing
08:29with the carrot, then Jeremy's son, Jeremy Jr., I don't know the kid's name, right? Jeremy Jr.,
08:38if Jeremy Jr., let's just say Jr. for a second, so if Jr. can't overthrow Jeremy, then Jr. can't get
08:45the highest quality female, and that's bad. He has also seen his father, I assume, not show a massive
08:53amount of deference and respect to male hierarchy, because Jeremy is an independent thinker and quite
09:00rebellious and so on, right? So, he has seen, maybe he's seen his own father challenge older males,
09:07or at least not mindlessly agree with them. Maybe he's seen his own father challenge his
09:12grandfather, and so on, right? Jeremy's father, and not in any sort of hostile or combative way,
09:17but just, you know, whatever, right? Maybe he rolls his eyes, maybe whatever it is, maybe the
09:22grandfather, Jr.'s grandfather is a bit of a normie, and all of that, right? So, I'm sure that Jeremy is a
09:30successful entrepreneur, and he's got, like, 250,000 followers on X, so Jeremy is a rebel. Jeremy has
09:38overthrown a particular kind of hierarchy, or at least doesn't take it particularly seriously.
09:43So, Jeremy Jr., right, his son, is instinctively kind of inhaling the rebelliousness of his father,
09:50and looks at his father and says, okay, so successful males do not take orders.
09:58Understand? Because you want to be, as a successful male in our evolution, you want to be in the
10:04position of giving orders, not taking orders, because that's all that happened throughout most
10:09of human history, is some men gave orders, and most men took orders. And the ones who gave orders,
10:15the men who gave orders, were the men who had the most power, the most resources, and got the most
10:22high-quality females. So, it's kind of funny, right? So, as a male, when you are raising a boy,
10:31you have to let him buck the hierarchy, or you're going to break him. You're going to break him.
10:39You have to let him rebel. You have to let him buck the hierarchy. You have to let him disagree with you
10:44and win. I mean, there's studies on mice. I think Dr. Peterson has cited this, too, but there are
10:51studies in mice that if there's an older, stronger mice, it's play-fighting with the younger, weaker
10:55mice, a mouse. If you are cleaning the vacuum cleaner, are you not the vacuum cleaner? If you are
11:04waiting for the waiter, are you not the waiter? So, if the larger, stronger mouse does not let the
11:11younger, weaker mouse win. At least a third of the time, the younger, weaker mouse will start playing.
11:16When you are teaching your children games or sports, you have to let them win from time to time.
11:23Otherwise, you know, this ridiculous thing of like the, imagine LeBron James, you know, slam dunking and,
11:29you know, power moving his, like, I don't know, five-year-old boy or something. It would be,
11:34be kind of sad, right? And my daughter and I will regularly engage in mock debates and it's a great
11:45deal of fun. It also has a good kind of intensity to it, which can be positive, usually is. And she
11:52needs to win. And by the by, she does win. She is really, really good at this kind of puzzling things
12:00out. So, this is the kind of stuff that you miss out on. So, I would guess that Jeremy
12:06does not respect the male hierarchy and does his own thing in defiance of older and more powerful
12:14males. I'm just going off the New Hampshire thing and what I remember from the interview.
12:19And I say this with all due respect to Jeremy. He seems like a good guy and, you know, this is a,
12:23this is just a tweak, right? So, Jeremy Jr. has seen his father buck the hierarchy, refused
12:30to take orders, be annoyed at taking orders and express frustration and also be dominant. And
12:35thus, he has pecked his way up through the male hierarchy. So, he looks at his father and says,
12:42oh, yeah, you totally have to defy males in order to be successful. I love dad. I want to be like dad.
12:48So, I'm going to refuse orders because dad refuses orders and dad doesn't like getting bossed around
12:53and dad likes to be higher, high up in the hierarchy. So, I'm going to be like dad and I'm not going to,
12:59I'm going to please dad by not picking up the carrot because dad doesn't pick up the carrot.
13:06Now, I get, you understand that this is how a two-year-old's brain is going to work.
13:12I emulate dad. I do what dad does. And you can see all of these things, right? There's a,
13:17a cute little scene in the movie Jaws, of which there are not a huge number of cute little scenes,
13:22where Roy Scheider, as the father, is sitting with his little boy opposite him and the little boy is
13:32copying everything that Roy Scheider does. Roy Scheider flexes his fingertips and clasps his hands
13:37together. The little boy tries that. Roy Scheider crosses his hands. I think the little boy does
13:43that. Roy Scheider makes a, as Chief Brody, Roy Scheider makes a, a sort of terrifying grimace of
13:51a face, does a good job with it too. And then Roy Scheider, Roy Scheider's boy, oh, in the movie,
13:58the kid does the same thing, which is super cute. So, I mean, this is what kids do. They,
14:03they copy, they emulate. I remember when my daughter had a little accident when she was younger,
14:09fell off a scooter. And I, I described what happened to people. And then when my daughter
14:17was asked what happened, she used almost the exact same phrases to describe what happened. I mean,
14:22this, this copy paste, right? This is how language and culture, right? They, they, to ape is to imitate,
14:27right? And, and we are bald apes in a way, right? So, so the interesting question as a parent is,
14:35why is my child not picking up the carrot? And that's a fascinating question, isn't it? I think
14:41it's a very interesting question. Now, it's not because my child hates me and it's not because my
14:45child doesn't respect the rules and it's not because, right? But the, the question is, so you
14:52always look inward as a parent, right? When your children are doing something, particularly when
14:56they're young, when you are pretty much the sole influence, right? So what you do is you look inward
15:01and you say, huh, that's interesting. My son is not picking up the carrot. I wonder why. So you'd
15:08have to look inward and you'd say, okay, has something happened in my life that my child has
15:14been around? And it, you know, honestly, it can just be overhearing. It can be tone or whatever it
15:18is, right? Has my son ever seen me question the rules or not want to obey them? Well, of course he has
15:29because you're a, um, a New Hampshire guy, right? So live free or die, right? So of course your son
15:38has seen that. So is my son copying me? Right? I mean, things could happen and you would also look
15:45for something proximate. So has, did something happen over the last day or two or three wherein
15:51I said, I don't want to obey these rules. I don't respect this, you know, whatever person
15:57in authority, it could be a cop or a politician or someone on TV or a president, whatever it
16:02is, right? So has my son experienced me not wanting to follow rules and defying a hierarchy?
16:14Huh? Well, of course he has. Of course he has. It's pretty funny. I just passed a sign
16:21from a butcher that says, we like pig, but some again, not lie. It's cute. So of course he has,
16:31Jeremy, come on, man. Of course he's seen you defy authority. And if I remember rightly,
16:37you've had challenges with deplatforming or things like that. So yeah, hierarchy has worked against you.
16:43You don't like the hierarchy that's currently in society and you want to move up in the hierarchy
16:48or if you can't move up in the hierarchy because it's grossing, like you want to change it, right?
16:54So if you grew up in the mafia and you're a good guy, you don't want to move up in the mafia.
16:58Maybe you want to join the police force or somewhere else where you're high up in the hierarchy.
17:03So Jeremy, my friend, has your son ever been around you when you have either directly or indirectly
17:12expressed frustration with hierarchy and wanted to rebel against that hierarchy and not obey the
17:20rules. Of course he has. Friend, so he's imitating you. It's a compliment. And he's trying to preserve
17:29his capacity to defy a hierarchy, to not obey rules, to displease the alpha, i.e. his own father.
17:41Women are not born to surmount their mothers, to defy and overcome and, quote, beat their mothers,
17:49because female child-raising contributions are cooperative. But males grew up in a strict hierarchy
17:57of excellence and win-lose, wherein your desire to win has got to be everything. I guarantee you,
18:06Jeremy, you did not get two quarter million followers on X and whatever else you've got
18:09and all the great entrepreneurial stuff you've done. You didn't get all of that by slavishly
18:15pleasing people and never disagreeing or disobeying any suggestions, rules, whatever it is,
18:22right? I mean, I'm sure you've pushed the edge of terms of service, right? So boys are hardwired
18:29to defy their fathers as practice for defying the alphas in their own environment and to peck and claw
18:40and fight and dig and scratch and bite their way to the top of the hierarchy as best they can.
18:46That's boys. That's you. That's me. That's boys. We have to be disagreeable. We have to defy
18:56alphas, elders, fathers, those in charge. We have to defy the being at the bottom of the hierarchy
19:04as children are in general. And whenever we start, we're at the bottom of the hierarchy. You start a
19:10company, you're at the bottom of the hierarchy of the company. You start in any sport, you're the worst
19:14at the sport, right? So you start at the bottom of the hierarchy and you have to annoy people by
19:20elbowing them aside and getting to the top of the hierarchy. So you've modeled that. I guarantee you've
19:26modeled that. And so your son not wanting to pick up the carrot is a tribute to you. It's a gesture of
19:34respect for you. Can you imagine me getting angry at my child if she said something that was true
19:43but could upset people? Can you imagine? I mean, it would be crazy. And I'm not German. I'm not
19:52calling you crazy, right? I'm just saying that curiosity is how you get to these things. You
19:57don't just slam down in the hierarchy. Don't be the government for your child, especially if you're
20:04not so pro-political power. I mean, so now you could say, yes, but you should pick up
20:10the carrot. Like, that's different from defying an unjust hierarchy, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
20:16It's like, but not to a two-year-old. Not to a two-year-old. So my guess is what happened is
20:21the kid dropped the carrot and you were in a bad mood. Obviously, I don't know. I'm just telling you
20:27how I think it probably played out. Maybe you had been humiliated. Maybe you were forced. Maybe you
20:32got a big tax bill that you didn't expect. Maybe something happened that had you down in the hierarchy
20:40in some manner or in some way. And your child drops the carrot and then you want to re-establish
20:49authority because some authority in some manner had been taken away from you. Which happens,
20:55you know, it happens in life. And we never hang on to all our authority forever because
20:58we all get old and decrepit and, right? So, I mean, whoever's the alpha, I mean, it's the
21:03story of King Lear, right? Whoever's the alpha will not stay the alpha forever because,
21:07well, we get old and we get physically weak and we get, you know, less intellectually powerful. I hear,
21:16I've never experienced it myself, but I hear it happens to others, right? So, yeah, I mean,
21:21the peak of our intellectual abilities tends to be in our 20s and early 30s and so on, right?
21:27So, something happened that dropped you down in the hierarchy and you saw your son drop the
21:35carrot. And then you didn't ask nicely, hey, bud, would you mind grabbing that, please? You're like,
21:42pick up that carrot. Ooh, operation resist authority activated. Because it's how you say it,
21:50it's how you ask it, right? I remember I was half kidnapped by a bunch of insurance agents many years
21:55ago. I'll tell that story. And they took me out all day and I went to a whole conference with them
21:59and all of that because I didn't have a car and they wouldn't drop me at a subway. Anyways, at the
22:04conference, I remember the guy saying, oh, so yeah, you guys are a bunch of salespeople. And what that
22:09means is you'll do almost anything I ask and absolutely nothing I tell you to. You'll do
22:15anything I ask nicely for and almost nothing I order you to do. And men, the way that you activate,
22:23fight the power, fight the hierarchy is you give an order. So, you probably turned and you
22:29snapped at your son and you say, pick up that carrot now. And your son, his instincts, right?
22:35This is not, at two, we're not making big choices based on abstract ethics. Come on. That's not how,
22:42that's not how a two-year-old, it's all instinct. It's all memes and biology and instinct and hormones
22:49and gut and like it's, they're just balls of instincts. I mean, there's some reasoning going on,
22:55but it's not like they have access to any of the sort of abstractions, right? Not philosophical
23:00creatures. At two. So, it's all instinct. So, my guess is what happened is you felt low in the
23:08hierarchy, you snapped at your son. Pick up that carrot now. Now. And your son was like, oh, no,
23:14I don't. My instincts say to do what dad does and rebel against authority and not take orders. Because
23:20if I take orders, I can't get high quality females. If I take orders, it's like being a slave. It's
23:26being very low on the hierarchy. And I love dad who's higher up on the hierarchy. So, I don't want
23:31to end up being low on the hierarchy. So, I'm not going to pick up the carrot. Again, all instincts,
23:37right? You know, the unconscious runs 6,000 times faster than the conscious mind in evaluating these
23:42kinds of things. And so, your son is, I'm not, I'm not picking up the carrot because his instincts and
23:47his genes and his gut is saying to him, don't take orders. If you take orders, you'll be a slave.
23:54And you may not reproduce. Remember, a lot of men didn't reproduce. And the men who didn't
23:58reproduce the most were slaves who were taking orders. So, don't take orders. That's what his
24:01gut, his genes is saying. Be like dad. Be up in the hierarchy. Don't take orders. So, I bet you
24:08snapped at him. And it's not a big blame thing. I'm just talking about the causality, right? We all snap
24:13at our children from time to time, right? It's not the end of the world, right? It doesn't have to
24:16escalate into a four-hour soul-crushing standoff. So, you snapped at your son. And because he loves
24:23you and respects you, and you don't take orders, or at least you don't like taking orders, or at
24:26least you'll fight orders wherever possible, he's like, oh, okay, I'll be like dad. And I won't take
24:31orders. So, he won't take orders. Because he wants to be like you. And he wants to get access to high
24:37quality females. So, he's not going to take orders. Because a lot of this stuff is genetic as well.
24:43Like, you are fighting genes a lot of times. Like, a lot of personality aspects, a lot of aspects,
24:50I won't say quirks, but a lot of aspects of personality, they're genetic. Hard genetics.
24:56You're trying to bully your son into changing his eye color, or his hair color. It's not going to work.
25:04Well, if I bully my son, he'll be taller. Nope. So, you say to your son, pick up that carrot now. Now.
25:13And he won't do it. Because his resist authority, don't take orders, survival of the genes, be like
25:21dad, all of this stuff kicks in. And he's like, no. And then you have a choice. And you can say,
25:27okay, so how would I feel if someone ordered me to do something? Jeremy Kaufman, pick that up right
25:33now. Like, no. Because you're a male. So, you resist orders. Because you want to be higher up in the
25:40hierarchy. So, you have a choice. If you say, pick up that carrot now. And your son says, no. And you
25:48say, oh, okay. How would I feel if I was just talked to in that kind of way? If somebody just
25:54gave me an order. How would I feel if my wife said, Jeremy Kaufman, pick up that carrot now.
26:00Or maybe, I don't know what his middle name. If she triple names him, you're doomed, right?
26:04Jeremy Basil Kaufman. Anyway. So, sorry for me to give him a gay middle name. But that's my middle
26:10name. So, there. So, you say, oh, that was a bit harsh. I say, you know what? I'm sorry. That was
26:17really rude. I'll get the carrot. I shouldn't have snapped at you. I'm so sorry. Like, you're
26:22right. Thank you for not obeying me if I'm being snappy, right? Or impatient. You know,
26:28and again, we all have bad moods and we all can be impatient and snappy. So, I mean, the
26:34important thing in parenting in life is not to be perfect, but just to be honest. If I had
26:40dropped something at school, how would I feel if the teacher said, pick that up now or else?
26:46Of course, you'd want to resist. You'd hate it. You'd hate being talked to in that kind
26:50of way. That's why I don't tell people what to do. One of the reasons. So, if you snap
26:56at your kid, like, I guarantee you, Jeremy, come on. I guarantee you, you didn't say, oh,
27:02but you dropped that carrot. Would you mind picking it up, please? Thank you. Appreciate
27:07it. No, it became a thing. It became an aggressive thing. It became a hierarchy thing. It became
27:12a dominance thing. And your son fought like hell.
27:16And you broke that. And why? Because you weren't asking questions. You got to put yourself
27:22in your kid's shoes. If you want your children to have empathy, you need to empathize with
27:26your children. How would I feel if I was two and somebody 10 to 15 times my size gave me
27:34a snappy order? Well, I'd rebel too. So, you got to empathize. How would I feel if somebody
27:44with infinite authority over me just ordered me to do something? How would
27:50what you feel? Right? So, if you are, I don't know, you're going through security at the
27:58airport. Some agent is like, take that belt off right now. I mean, you would be kind of
28:06annoyed, right? I mean, you do it, right? Because you got to get on the plane, but you'd
28:09be annoyed. So, did you snap at your son? And if you snapped at your son, and he said no,
28:16because you snapped at him, then you apologize. Of course, right? Because you, it's not right
28:22to snap at your kid for dropping a carrot. Just, you ask nicely, right? Because you want
28:26your kid to be polite and all of that, right? So, you fire off something at your kid, your
28:31kid fires back no, and then you escalate your aggression. And your son's genes are like,
28:38okay, well, we got to, we got to try and break through this. We got to survive this. We got
28:42that come out. We don't, we can't come out on top because we're two, but we're not going
28:46to come out broken. Because anybody who's a libertarian, who uses size and intimidation
28:53to force obedience out of their children, doesn't understand a fucking thing about libertarianism.
28:58It's not a philosophy for the state or the government, primarily and fundamentally, it's a philosophy
29:03for the home. Because that you can control, quality of your relationships. You can't control
29:08what the government does, but you can control whether you're aggressive towards your children.
29:14And this should not be big news. Of course, I've been talking about this for decades, right?
29:20That you are the government to your children. And if you don't like the government ordering
29:25you around, don't order your children around. If you didn't like teachers ordering you around,
29:32snapping at you, don't do it to your children. And if your child has seen you being discontented
29:41and unhappy with being ordered around and resisting it, then don't be too fucking shocked. If they
29:50don't like being ordered around and they resist it. It's just curiosity. Hey, say, pick up that
30:00carrot now. No. Okay, that's your indication that your child is mirroring something back to you that's
30:06important. That they're going through something that's important for you to understand. My child
30:11normally is quite helpful. Why does my child not want to pick up the carrot? What a fantastic
30:18opportunity to learn about your child and yourself. What an amazing opportunity. Like these doors open
30:24in relationships where people do things that are surprising. They do things that are surprising.
30:31And when people are being surprising, that's when you get to learn the most about them.
30:36Because it's an unusual situation. When I was newly married, my wife is a very even-tempered person.
30:43And once or twice after we got married, she got quite exasperated with me. That's
30:49fascinating because that's not at all her natural state of being. It's quite far from her natural
30:55state of being. So we had conversations about that and we learned a lot about that. Wow.
31:01So this is why it is. That's really interesting. So your son says no to something. Great. Especially
31:09if your son is normally quite cooperative, right? Your son says no. What a fantastic opportunity
31:16to find out why. When people behave in ways that go against their normal habits, that is because
31:25they are experiencing stimuli that is going against their normal environment. I don't tend to run at
31:33full tilt through the woods, but if I'm being chased by a bear, I kind of am, right? Doing that. So you
31:40tell your son, and even if you ask nicely, right? Let's say that I'm completely wrong and Jeremy
31:46did not snap at Jeremy Jr. Let's say that he asked, hey, hey, listen, you just, you just picked that,
31:52you dropped that carrot. Would you mind grabbing it and picking it up, please? No. Okay. That's
31:58even more interesting. See, it's not, it's just interesting. It's just data. So what is going on?
32:06Maybe your child has a bellyache. They're hiding from you because they don't want to upset you.
32:10Maybe your child has a headache. Maybe your child had a really bad dream involving a carrot. Maybe,
32:15like, I'm not kidding, right? Maybe the last time your child picked something up this morning,
32:21he bumped his head and it really hurt, right? Maybe he saw your wife, he saw his mother give you orders
32:30and you defied them and he wants to be like you. I don't know. But the problem is if all you do is
32:35muscle and break his will, you'll never know. You'll never know. Why does someone say no? Well,
32:43if you're snapping at them, it's because you're snapping at them. And particularly as a boy,
32:47he can't afford that. Like, his genes simply cannot afford that. Because in the four-hour
32:53standoff, which, by the way, is a complete eternity, of course, for a child. Like, at two,
33:00four hours is like four days or four weeks for us. So why was your son struggling so hard? Well,
33:07he was struggling because he wants to have the ability to defy the hierarchy so he can get the
33:12highest quality female. But if he is unable to defy the hierarchy, if the hierarchy wins,
33:20if the alpha male wins, then he is a slave. He can't win against the hierarchy and therefore
33:28he cannot defy the hierarchy and therefore he cannot get the highest quality females and therefore
33:34he's low on the totem pole. And that's it. That's it. And that is now pounded into his mind,
33:42his heart, his soul. Now, I'm not saying irrevocably, like it's one standoff, but it's a
33:48pretty big one. And this is why it all went viral, right? Because most people have had that kind of
33:54standoff in the past with parents or teachers or something like that, right? There's a famous scene
33:59in the movie The Breakfast Club, where the Judd Nelson character keeps mouthing off to the principal
34:07and the principal just keeps assigning him more and more weekend detentions, right? What do you do?
34:16What do you do? Where does your son stand in the hierarchy, not just of the family, but of life
34:22itself. If your son cannot at all defeat the hierarchy, if he says no, he doesn't want to do
34:30something, he's testing to see if he's a slave or has the potential for being an alpha. Is he going to
34:37take orders his whole life or does he at least have the chance of giving orders? And what an amazing
34:46and assertive attitude of will to say, I will not surrender. I will not surrender. And then what
34:56happened? Well, what happened was his genes said, well, we now have to calculate our best odds of
35:04survival and reproduction, because genes will take low quality reproduction over no reproduction,
35:10of course, right? Because no reproduction is the absolute end of the lineage for that combination of
35:15genes, for your son's genes. So your son's genes are saying the following, resist, resist, resist.
35:21If you can't win, you have to cave. Because if your father will not let you exercise any will in
35:30opposition to his, then you are going to have to surrender to him, because otherwise, your chances of
35:37survival go down, historically. Because he might not bond with you, he might not care about you as much,
35:45he might be slower to protect you from predators, you might get less food, because he has less
35:50loyalty. Do not anger your caregiver too much, right? And this is why it's such an unfair battle
35:58between a grown adult and a toddler, a little two-year-old, because a two-year-old can't win,
36:04can't win at all. But he'll try. He'll try. Is it possible for me to not be at the bottom of the
36:14hierarchy? Is it possible for me to overthrow an alpha, to challenge the hierarchy, to blah, blah,
36:20blah, blah, blah, blah? Is it possible for this to happen? If so, I will be one kind of person.
36:25I will strive. I will challenge authority. I will think for myself. I will try as hard as I can to
36:34put my individual will and sovereign consciousness into effect. I will make decisions. I will defy
36:40hierarchy with the support of my father. In other words, is my father a hypocrite, right? Because
36:45my father defies authority, but he doesn't allow me to defy authority. And of course, the father can say,
36:51yes, but I'm in the right. The carrot should be picked up. It's not about the carrot. Everybody knows
36:54it's not about the carrot at all. But if you break the will of the child and you say, you will never
37:02be allowed to disagree with me. You will take orders. You will obey. Damn it! Okay, then you create a
37:11different kind of person. I mean, certainly more of the slave mentality. And instead of going out
37:18hunting, he will just pick up the scraps left over. He will try to survive not through independent
37:25thought and disagreement and disagreeableness. He will not challenge the hierarchy. He will just try
37:30and find a way to survive by conforming. And he will be a baiter. And he will not have access to the
37:41highest quality females. And he will not make much money because the carrot is independence and
37:49defiance. And he's not allowed. So you just end up with a different kind of kid. And then what will
37:56happen is you'll get annoyed at the kid for being too deferential, for being too hesitant, which is
38:01something that you have sadly created. So I hope that makes sense. Freedomain.com slash donate to help
38:06out the show. And I'd love to hear your feedback. Peacefulparenting.com to get the facts. All the
38:13best. Bye.

Recommended