00:00They all knew each other, but where they sort of parted ways is that Savarkar wanted the RSS to almost be subsumed in the political struggle of the Hindu Mahasabha for, you know, to bid elections and Hedgibar says, no, that's not our job.
00:18And then Savarkar starts criticizing the sun a lot. But the sun never criticizes Savarkar. And it takes this Hindutva ideology and carries it forward. But the sun also respects Gandhi. In fact, in their morning prayer, they remember Gandhi.
00:37And don't forget that in the Vajpay, you know, BJP 1.0, Gandhian socialism was in their election manifesto. And it's only this 2.0 after 2014 that they brought Savarkar or at least Hindutva to the forefront.
00:561920s were a turning point. You mentioned the failure of the non-cooperation movement when Gandhi pulled back for moral reasons.
01:06But both Jinnah and Savarkar thought of Gandhi as a very impractical and irrational person. In fact, in Lord Desai's book, which I was skimming over,
01:17he quotes these letters and excerpts from the statements of Jinnah, who was very ironically, but politely saying, well, Gandhi will wait for his inner voice.
01:29He's an impractical man. In a letter he wrote, you're in Shegao, which was near Malta, and you live in an ashram. You're spinning your charkha.
01:39You really don't know what's happening. And Savarkar went to the point of calling Gandhi a madcap.
01:44And in Marathi, he wrote this thing that these Gandhians, you know, with their strange ideas of non-violence, are going to destroy us.
01:53So the next moment to me, a very interesting moment, which brings me to your question, was the 1940s.
01:59And, or maybe 1939, it starts when the Congress, during the World War, Second World War, resigns.
02:07They're in the majority in all the provinces.
02:09And it's one of those ironies of history that Savarkar, as one of my friends from JNU told me this afternoon,
02:17was actually released, not by the British, but by the Bombay government, released Savarkar, and he came back to Bombay from Ratnagiri.
02:26Anyhow, so all these governments, the Congress was in the majority, resigned.
02:30And Jinnah jumped into the vacuum, and so did Hindu Mahasabha.
02:36So, Hindu Mahasabha actually formed governments in Bengal, Punjab, and if I'm not mistaken, in the northwest, west frontier province,
02:44in cohorts, with, or cahoots, with the Muslim League, another one of those ironies of history.
02:52Now, did Savarkar know about Mary's closeness to Edmina?
02:57I don't know.
02:57But, during this period, when all the Congress leaders, except for the young Turks, you know,
03:04Asaf Ali, Aruna Asaf Ali, Achit Patwar, the socialist, revolutionary wing of the Congress,
03:11they were out, and underground, all the Congress leaders were in jail.
03:16We delve into the fact that each of them had very different ideologies, that is Gandhi, Jinnah, and Savarkar.
03:28And each of them gave something to the freedom struggle in their own way.
03:34You may agree with their ideology, you might disagree with it,
03:38but the fact was that they led us to the moment that India got its independence,
03:44and also the partition took place at the same time.
03:49I wanted to first ask, actually, Makaram, because he has written this wonderful book.
03:59But, I would like to ask you about the two books that were written by two of the leading characters
04:06that we are talking about today, that is, Gandhi wrote a book called Hind Swaraj,
04:12and Savarkar wrote about the first independence struggle of India in 1857.
04:19These books were written from very different points of view.
04:23Would you like to comment on that, just to lead us into the discussion further,
04:27on how we came to the point where both of them seemed, at one stage,
04:33to be opposed to everything they stood for?