Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 9 months ago
Two Indian students were tragically murdered in Canada within a single week, sparking fears of growing anti-Indian sentiment in the country. Canadian journalist Daniel Bordman criticised local authorities for mishandling the investigations and highlighted a rising culture of hostility towards Indians. The first victim, Himanshi Khurana, was found dead in Toronto on December 19, followed by Shivank Avasthi on December 23. Police investigations are ongoing, but experts and community members have raised serious concerns about the safety of Indians in Canada.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00We just know that the name of the victim and that he was shot dead.
00:05But this is just a murder, so this is not that serious to the Toronto police.
00:08Daniel, thank you very much for speaking to A&I.
00:10In a very short notice, I'll begin by quickly asking you,
00:13two Indian students were found murdered in Canada in a fortnight.
00:17What do you know about the matter?
00:19What is the Canadian police doing about it?
00:22The consulate has expressed anguish over it.
00:25What have you learned about this matter so far?
00:26Okay, so, I mean, the two murders are probably not connected
00:30because they're in different provinces, you know,
00:32more than a day's drive away from each other.
00:36So the most recent murder in Toronto, if we know it's a murder,
00:40we just know that the name of the victim and that he was shot dead.
00:46We don't know why, who, what, when, how.
00:50So to this most recent murder, the public knows next to nothing about it
00:56other than there is a murder.
00:58So if you're wondering what the police are doing,
01:00I mean, they're probably looking into it, but this is Canadian police.
01:03So I expect extreme incompetence.
01:08And if this was a mean comment online about, you know,
01:14a government official that was not white,
01:18the person might be in jail for 50 years.
01:20But this is just a murder, so this is not that serious to the Toronto police.
01:24They will fumble it.
01:25And if they don't manage to fumble it and they find the person responsible,
01:28they would be put in jail for maybe a maximum of three years
01:31before being let out to rampage the streets again.
01:34So that's what the police is up to.
01:37Daniel, how does it, you know,
01:41this incident has also raised concerns about safety of Indian students in Canada
01:45because we have seen some incidents in the past as well.
01:49What is your comment on that?
01:51And also, you know,
01:51there was a report that an Indian man died of suspected cardiac arrest
01:56after waiting for more than eight hours.
01:57He was waiting for a treatment in hospital.
02:00So what does these things tell you about the situations of the,
02:04of Indian nationals in Canada?
02:06Well, okay.
02:07These two things are completely unconnected.
02:10Okay.
02:11So to go to the hospital, this is, this is what every Canadian,
02:14this is not an Indian discrimination.
02:16This is socialized medicine and the Canadian healthcare system
02:19not being updated to handle.
02:22I mean, we are a country of 30 million people.
02:25We're beginning of Trudeau.
02:26We're now a country of 40 million people,
02:28mostly through direct migration, which say what you will about that.
02:32But one of the things we should have done is if we had hospital services
02:37that were still failing and understaffed and underworked at 30 million,
02:40we should have increased capacity.
02:42We did not increase capacity in the medical field.
02:44The only people we added into the medical field in the last 10 years are
02:47bureaucrats to, to pretend with, we're adding more medical fields.
02:51So we've just made the problem even worse by swamping a net,
02:54a bureaucracy onto a mass problem.
02:56So that's why people are dying in hospitals.
02:59Now, to the safety of Indian students in general, I don't think the problem with Canada is that it's unsafe as of yet,
03:09unless you get into gang warfare, which is another problem brought up by some migration problems.
03:18But in terms of safety, Canada is still a relatively safe country.
03:28I've been to India.
03:29I've driven on the roads there.
03:30I think you're more likely to die in a car crash on an Indian highway than you are to die in a homicide,
03:35you know, most places in the world.
03:37So in terms of safety, I think the safety risk is not really what we're talking about.
03:42I mean, you're talking about more climate, a climate of discrimination that's growing.
03:46And that, that, that's a problem, right?
03:48Because most Indians, if they would come here, would not be murdered and shot dead.
03:52And if that's your line for safety, then it's whatever.
03:55But are things getting a little bit more uncomfortable socially in Canada,
03:59especially as it goes for immigrants, particularly Indians?
04:02Yes, yes.
04:03There's a rising culture of, you know, anti-Indian sentiment being pushed by a lot of different factors.
04:11Some of them you're familiar with in India.
04:13But, yeah, I don't think safety is, is, is the big problem we're talking about.
04:19Although this is Canada and is getting, it is less safe than it was 20 years ago
04:22when it was an incredibly, incredibly safe country.
04:25Now it's just a pretty safe country instead of a very safe country.
04:29Daniel, just one more question talking about those Indian students dying.
04:33How does this incident fit into the broader context of violent crime in Toronto this year?
04:38And are police or city officials offering any insight into trends or patterns that might help the public understand the risk?
04:47No, the police have no insights of value whatsoever.
04:49And this is sort of, yeah, this is the slow decline of the Canadian institutions where, you know,
04:55a shooting 20 years, 15 years ago would have been massive, massive news.
04:59But now we're growing more accustomed to homicide in the city and in the country.
05:04So that's unfortunate.
05:06And what are the police doing?
05:07The police are a big part of it, too, through either negligence.
05:12Some of the police officers are good.
05:13But again, the police boards and the politics around policing, we've sort of imbibed this sort of de-policing strategy.
05:19So the Canadian theory of policing says that crime comes from racism and police cause racism.
05:28So when you have crime in certain areas, the answer is not to use police to stop crime.
05:34It's actually to blame the police, take the police away and enable, just because the police are causing racism with racial profiling
05:41and all the ridiculous things that they come up with in a university classroom.
05:45But essentially they say, after 10 years of Trudeau, this has turned the country much, much less safe.
05:50So the police are demoralized.
05:52The good police are demoralized.
05:53The bad police have been moved to positions of power, and they're ideologically captured by the nonsense theories.
06:00So what are the theories they're putting out towards the public?
06:03Probably something in the lines of racism causes violence.
06:06So let's reduce racism with some sort of HR sensitivity training at a government workplace.
06:12And if you say, is that going to reduce crime in Canada?
06:15The answer is no, it's not.
06:16But we're going to continue to, I don't think anyone believes it, but we're going to continue to push it.
06:21Because again, it's quite lucrative for the people who get the contracts to do that.
06:24Most of them are involved in the Liberal Party in some way.
06:27So that's sort of what we're doing with the crime.
06:29We're doing nothing productive about the crime.
06:31They will be continuing the crime.
06:32It will get worse.
06:33It's not as bad.
06:34It's not like a slum in Bangladesh where you've got to fight your way to the top.
06:38It's still a first world country, but it is on a downward trend in terms of safety.
06:42But it's not at like, you know, you're safer in Canada than you are in the border of India and Pakistan,
06:49you know, dancing between those two armies.
06:51So, let's get started.

Recommended