00:00A recurring complaint among anime fans is that male protagonists never lose their cool, never get scared, never cry.
00:08When a sensitive or fragile character appears, many viewers react with rejection.
00:13Even in forums, you can read that Deku from My Hero Academia is a crybaby and some don't like that.
00:21Why this animosity toward more vulnerable heroes?
00:24Is it valid to discriminate against a character for their tears and emotions?
00:30The crybaby hero trope describes a male protagonist who is initially weak, indecisive, or fearful,
00:37and who frequently displays emotional fragility, even crying, when faced with danger.
00:43However, as a fan of Subaru Natsuki, Zero points out,
00:49crying for valid reasons doesn't make you a crybaby.
00:52Subaru only cries for valid reasons.
00:54In other words, these are characters who genuinely cry because of trauma or emotion, not because of mere narrative weakness.
01:03Although it often annoys the audience, this trope emphasizes that crying is not a flaw, but a human expression.
01:10Shinji Ikari, Neon Genesis Evangelion.
01:14A traumatized young pilot, famous for his initial tears and protests when boarding the EVA.
01:20Many fans point to him as the archetype of the whiny hero.
01:24The same discussion thread uses Shinji as an example of a wimp or sympathetic character.
01:30Yukiteru Amano, Mirai Nikki, Future Diary.
01:34A shy and insecure protagonist who receives severe criticism for his passivity.
01:39One user called him a useless coward who never changes and the worst protagonist,
01:44summarizing the hatred of part of the fandom for his whiny character.
01:49Renton Thurston, Eureka 7.
01:51A dreamy teenager faced with harsh realities.
01:55One review ironically pointed out that Renton's whiny behavior gets on the nerves of anyone who sees it.
02:02Thus, Renton is cited as an example of a melancholic and complaining hero.
02:07Subaru Natsuki, Re, Zero.
02:10An ordinary young man trapped in a hellish world.
02:13His emotional reactions and repeated defeats earned him the nickname Crybaby.
02:19In fact, he is mentioned alongside Shinji in complaints.
02:23Look at Shinji Subaru.
02:25Describing him among the protagonists hated for being supposedly weak.
02:29Izuku Dekumiteria, My Hero Academia.
02:32A persistent and sensitive hero who cries with emotion.
02:36Although many adore him, some detractors criticize him for this trait.
02:40One fan explains that in typical shounen, everyone is tough and Deku contrasts by being a crybaby.
02:48Something that certain people don't like.
02:50Rigid expectations of the hero.
02:52Fandom establishes strict masculine standards.
02:56As one user summarizes, heroes never lose their cool, never get scared, never cry.
03:02It is assumed that the protagonist must always be brave and unflappable.
03:07Traditional masculinity.
03:09The crying hero is stigmatized.
03:12He is labeled simp, beta, or wimp for acting more feminine or showing doubt.
03:18This offensive language reflects that some fans see his tears as a threat to the classic virile ideal.
03:25Personal identification.
03:27Many fans are also young men who see themselves reflected in the protagonist.
03:31One commentator notes that 85% of anime is male, and by default they identify more with male MCs.
03:39So they are very critical when they don't fit the expected mold.
03:44In other words, when looking at a character who exhibits their own insecurities,
03:48some prefer to distance themselves by getting angry.
03:51As another voice warns,
03:52There is nothing we hate more than our own flaws.
03:56Real emotional depth.
03:58Many tearful heroes suffer genuine trauma.
04:01For example,
04:03Shinji Ikari has lived in an apocalyptic world.
04:06He is Earth's only hope,
04:08and yet he doesn't want to fight.
04:10He wants to run away.
04:11His tears are not a whim,
04:13but a reaction to the horror he has had to endure.
04:16Resilience in the face of pain.
04:18Subaru Natsuki relives death repeatedly.
04:21His suffering is extreme.
04:24As one fan comments,
04:26Is Subaru a crybaby?
04:28Sure, I cry too if I saw my friends die over and over again.
04:32Crying, in his case,
04:34is the human response to incessant pain.
04:36Personal growth.
04:38His tears do not stall the story.
04:40They propel it forward.
04:42One defender of Deku emphasizes that crying is not a weakness,
04:46just overflowing emotions,
04:48and is an important part of his development.
04:50Thus, characters like Deku learn through their emotions,
04:54becoming stronger or more empathetic.
04:57Toxic masculinity.
04:58Sometimes rejection reveals prejudice.
05:01One fan declares that being a crybaby is a good thing.
05:05Anyone who thinks otherwise doesn't understand anime
05:08or embodies toxic masculinity.
05:11In other words,
05:12demonizing crying may reflect rigid gender attitudes,
05:15not narrative merits.
05:16Context and frequency.
05:19It's not that any hero who cries is rejected.
05:22Characters like Naruto or Tanjiro also cry at key moments,
05:27out of pain or love,
05:29and are adored.
05:30The difference is usually in the context.
05:32When a hero cries for a loved one,
05:35or out of personal frustration that drives their growth,
05:38the audience accepts it more easily.
05:40In contrast,
05:42if he cries repeatedly without seeing any progress,
05:45as happens during long arcs of Rii,
05:48Zero, for example,
05:49some fans become impatient.
05:51Ultimately,
05:52it is the background and evolution
05:54that usually justify
05:56or exasperate the protagonist's tears.
05:59This debate highlights
06:00our expectations of the ideal hero.
06:03Should these characters who cry disappear?
06:06Not at all.
06:07They reflect real conflicts and vulnerabilities.
06:09As one fan points out,
06:12the community has something
06:13against the more emotionally sensitive characters.
06:16Perhaps the real question
06:17is what this reveals about us.
06:20Heroes who cry invite us
06:21to rethink masculinity in anime.
06:25To appreciate that courage
06:26can also be accompanied by tears.
06:28What do you think?
06:29Tell us in the comments.
06:30Let us know.
06:32Let us know.
06:41We will go with youriquez.
06:43Goodbye.
06:43Bye.
06:43Bye.
06:44Bye.
06:45You
Comments