- 3 months ago
"Sins of Silence" can refer to several different plots, most notably a 1996 TV movie about a former nun who becomes a rape counselor and defies a court order to protect a victim.
Category
🎥
Short filmTranscript
00:00:00A
00:00:04A
00:00:08A
00:00:10A
00:00:14A
00:00:16A
00:00:18A
00:00:20A
00:00:22A
00:00:24A
00:00:26A
00:00:28A
00:00:30A
00:00:32A
00:00:34A
00:00:38A
00:00:40A
00:00:42A
00:00:44A
00:00:46A
00:00:48A
00:00:50A
00:00:52A
00:00:54A
00:00:56A
00:00:58A
00:01:00A
00:01:02A
00:01:04A
00:01:06A
00:01:08A
00:01:10A
00:01:12A
00:01:14A
00:01:16A
00:01:18A
00:01:20A
00:01:22A
00:01:24A
00:01:26A
00:01:28A
00:01:30A
00:01:32A
00:01:34A
00:01:36A
00:01:38A
00:01:40A
00:01:42A
00:01:44A
00:01:46A
00:01:48A
00:01:50A
00:01:52A
00:01:54A
00:01:56A
00:01:58A
00:02:00A
00:02:02A
00:02:04A
00:02:06A
00:02:08A
00:02:10A
00:02:12A
00:02:14A
00:02:16A
00:02:18A
00:02:20A
00:02:22A
00:02:24A
00:02:26A
00:02:28A
00:02:30A
00:02:32A
00:02:34A
00:02:36A
00:02:38A
00:02:40A
00:02:42A
00:02:44A
00:02:46A
00:02:48A
00:02:50A
00:02:52A
00:02:54A
00:02:56A
00:02:58A
00:03:00A
00:03:02A
00:03:04A
00:03:06A
00:03:08A
00:03:26A
00:03:28A
00:03:30A
00:03:32A
00:03:34A
00:03:36A
00:03:38A
00:03:40A
00:03:42A
00:03:44A
00:03:46A
00:03:48A
00:03:50A
00:03:52A
00:03:54A
00:03:56A
00:03:58A
00:04:00A
00:04:02A
00:04:04A
00:04:06A
00:04:08A
00:04:10A
00:04:12A
00:04:14A
00:04:16A
00:04:18A
00:04:20A
00:04:22A
00:04:24A
00:04:26A
00:04:28A
00:04:30A
00:04:32A
00:04:34A
00:04:36A
00:04:38A
00:04:40A
00:04:42A
00:04:44A
00:04:46A
00:04:48A
00:04:50A
00:04:52A
00:04:54A
00:04:56A
00:04:58A
00:05:00A
00:05:02A
00:05:04A
00:05:06A
00:05:08A
00:05:10A
00:05:12A
00:05:14A
00:05:16A
00:05:18A
00:05:20A
00:05:22A
00:05:24A
00:05:26A
00:05:28A
00:05:30A
00:05:32A
00:05:34A
00:05:36A
00:05:38A
00:05:40A
00:05:42A
00:05:44A
00:05:46A
00:05:48A
00:05:50A
00:05:52A
00:05:54A
00:05:56A
00:05:58A
00:06:00A
00:06:02A
00:06:04A
00:06:06A
00:06:08A
00:06:10A
00:06:12A
00:06:14A
00:06:16A
00:06:18A
00:06:20A
00:06:22A
00:06:24A
00:06:26A
00:06:40A
00:06:48You can't force her to make a statement.
00:06:50I don't care how badly you want this case.
00:06:52Come on.
00:06:53Leave her alone, or I'm going straight to the press.
00:06:56Okay, you win.
00:06:58You want to protect her from me, then you go right ahead.
00:07:00I don't have time for this.
00:07:02Here are car keys. It's parked out front.
00:07:03You tell her to call me when she's ready to talk.
00:07:18You like it?
00:07:22I painted it myself, me and a friend.
00:07:24She's more the artist.
00:07:26Are you okay to drive?
00:07:27Yeah, I'm fine.
00:07:29Do you have somebody at home?
00:07:31Sure.
00:07:32Why don't you come talk to me tomorrow?
00:07:35I'm not really a talker.
00:07:37Might help.
00:07:48The thing is, some people are fine at first.
00:07:55But it gets tough.
00:07:57Nobody has to know but you and me.
00:08:0310.30?
00:08:06Okay.
00:08:09Call the office. They'll set it up for you.
00:08:18I was at this bar at Johnny B's.
00:08:28It's spring break.
00:08:28I'm only home for two weeks, and I saw this girl.
00:08:32Did you know her?
00:08:32No.
00:08:33But she was giving me the eye.
00:08:36Pretty soon she said, would I buy her a beer?
00:08:38You had sex?
00:08:40Yes.
00:08:41When did you hear from the district attorney's office?
00:08:45Menino called about 3.30 this morning.
00:08:47He said the police picked her up.
00:08:49They might need to talk to my son.
00:08:51There may be some trouble.
00:08:53What happened to your hand?
00:08:58Tennis.
00:08:59Someone see you do it?
00:09:01Yes.
00:09:06Don't worry.
00:09:07We'll be fine.
00:09:17We'll be fine.
00:09:47We'll be fine.
00:10:15I have a present for you.
00:10:43I'm cooking.
00:10:45It's very serious.
00:10:50You must choose.
00:10:55What?
00:10:57Nothing.
00:10:59You don't like it?
00:11:01What happened to you?
00:11:03What do you mean?
00:11:03This morning, I woke up, 6.30.
00:11:06Nobody home.
00:11:08I had school.
00:11:09At 6.30?
00:11:11Yes, cheerleading tryouts.
00:11:12So you chop your hair to be cheerleading.
00:11:15Just be grateful I was going to shave it.
00:11:22You have to choose.
00:11:29See?
00:11:30I make her today.
00:11:32Pink angel.
00:11:35Like you.
00:11:35Off, there.
00:11:40I'll be back.
00:11:50I'll be back.
00:11:50We're at Crisis Center. Good morning.
00:12:18Uh, the director.
00:12:20No, I'm sorry. The director isn't in right now. Can I take a message?
00:12:25Absolutely, Mr. DeFazio. I will tell her as soon as she comes in.
00:12:29Right. Bye-bye now.
00:12:30What happened to the heat?
00:12:32Oh, they called us in the morning.
00:12:34We're at Crisis Center. Could you hold, please?
00:12:37They said that, uh, we haven't paid the last three bills.
00:12:40Well, we can't just turn it off.
00:12:41Well, they said that now that we've got a director, we should be more responsible for our finances.
00:12:45Did we hear from Teresa Silvio?
00:12:47Nope.
00:12:47I knew it.
00:12:48Uh, I wouldn't bother if I were you. Teresa Silvio doesn't exist.
00:12:55What?
00:12:56We got a call from Joe Finn at the DA's office. Fake driver's license.
00:13:01And the plates on her car were stolen from, uh, Henry Lee in 1983.
00:13:05We're sorry. The number you have reached is no longer in service.
00:13:09I told him you got the same number that he did.
00:13:11So we said, thanks for your help.
00:13:13It didn't sound like thanks to me.
00:13:18You okay?
00:13:24Yeah, I'm fine.
00:13:25They said I'm fine.
00:13:28They said I'm fine.
00:13:28They said I'm fine.
00:13:55They said I'm fine.
00:14:16Molly McKinley.
00:14:22I've been watching you for the longest time.
00:14:24I couldn't decide who it was.
00:14:26First, I thought it was the Blessed Virgin
00:14:28telling me to start working on the garden.
00:14:32What have you found?
00:14:33It's, uh, something I left here when I was nine.
00:14:37All my worldly goods.
00:14:39In exchange for what?
00:14:42I wanted to be a saint.
00:14:43I got a letter from the Mother General.
00:14:46She said that you'd left the convent.
00:14:48She seemed to think it was best for you.
00:14:50It's a lot harder than I thought it would be.
00:14:53It's not a sin, you know, leaving a vocation.
00:14:58Doesn't mean you have to leave the church.
00:15:01I know.
00:15:04But you don't come by.
00:15:07I come by.
00:15:09I just can't seem to get through the door anymore.
00:15:13I saw the light.
00:15:35I thought maybe there was someone inside.
00:15:36Do you care if I smoke?
00:15:45It's okay if you do.
00:15:46I don't have to.
00:15:47No, it's fine.
00:15:50I showed us a lung once in science that had black holes.
00:15:53I think about it every time.
00:16:00You know, it's not very nice in here.
00:16:02You should get a better plant.
00:16:03You want to talk about it?
00:16:09About what?
00:16:11About why you came.
00:16:15Well, what's your name?
00:16:18Let's start with that.
00:16:20Sophie.
00:16:21Sophie what?
00:16:22Di Mario.
00:16:25I was thinking maybe I saw him after school.
00:16:27I was thinking he was following me.
00:16:31Did he?
00:16:32I don't think so, but it just keeps happening.
00:16:35I see him in weird places like I'm crazy.
00:16:38What places?
00:16:40This is stupid.
00:16:42I can't do this.
00:16:44Sophie.
00:16:45What's the point?
00:16:46I mean, it doesn't do any good.
00:16:47It might help you feel less crazy.
00:16:49Right.
00:16:50Tell me what happened.
00:16:52Just try.
00:16:53You can stop anytime you want.
00:16:55Who finds out?
00:16:57Nobody.
00:17:03I was at a bar.
00:17:05Yeah?
00:17:06I went with this friend of mine.
00:17:08And I see this guy, Tommy Bickley.
00:17:10He's in the paper sometimes.
00:17:12His family.
00:17:13He starts hitting on me.
00:17:15And I don't like it.
00:17:16So I leave.
00:17:16And the next thing I know, he runs me off the road.
00:17:19Why didn't you tell anyone?
00:17:21I'm not stupid.
00:17:22I was drinking.
00:17:2316 with a fake ID.
00:17:24I know what that means.
00:17:25What does it mean?
00:17:27The guys like him don't have to rape somebody like me.
00:17:30Did he rape you?
00:17:32What difference does it make?
00:17:34Who's going to believe it?
00:17:35I do.
00:17:36There was a witness.
00:17:37Even the DA thinks it's a good case.
00:17:38It doesn't matter.
00:17:39Why?
00:17:41Because you're afraid?
00:17:42My father works for them.
00:17:43Okay?
00:17:44Bickley Glass.
00:17:46Sophie, you think they're going to hurt him?
00:17:47They can't hurt him.
00:17:50If you bring charges, people are going to know.
00:17:52The union, newspapers.
00:17:53You don't know.
00:17:54You have a right to stand up for yourself.
00:17:57You don't know anything about it or my rights.
00:17:59So go.
00:18:01If you don't think this is doing you any good, you should go.
00:18:03Sophie, this is about you.
00:18:14I'm scared.
00:18:20All the time.
00:18:21Every time I leave my house.
00:18:24And I'm so tired and I keep thinking he has everything.
00:18:28Just like he always did.
00:18:29He has a life.
00:18:32Why does he get away with it?
00:18:34I want you to forget about your father.
00:18:36I want you to forget about the lawyers.
00:18:38and do what's going to be best for you.
00:18:46I want to tell someone.
00:19:08You're late.
00:19:13I was getting dressed.
00:19:17This registered?
00:19:19Next time, leave it at home.
00:19:23All right, here's the thing.
00:19:24You want to be careful how you tell the story.
00:19:26You can't lie, but you can't sound uncertain.
00:19:29And don't blame yourself.
00:19:30Maybe you shouldn't have gone to that bar.
00:19:31But you have to be confident, even if you're nervous.
00:19:34Because if he thinks that you are,
00:19:35then he's going to start to waffle and you have to expect that.
00:19:38You just don't want to send the wrong message.
00:19:40I'm not nervous.
00:19:40Good, because you shouldn't be.
00:19:42I can't prosecute this.
00:19:45Why?
00:19:46She lied about what happened.
00:19:48I didn't lie.
00:19:49You're 16, not 23.
00:19:50Used a fake ID, fake name, stolen plates.
00:19:53You have a witness.
00:19:54She was at a bar.
00:19:55So?
00:19:57How often do you go there?
00:19:59What difference does that make?
00:20:01Once a month?
00:20:01Once a week?
00:20:02Twice a week, maybe?
00:20:03Why do you go there?
00:20:03To meet guys?
00:20:04Sometimes.
00:20:04This is not a judgment.
00:20:05I'm just trying to tell you something.
00:20:06It doesn't matter what happened.
00:20:08She can't win.
00:20:10It isn't about winning.
00:20:11Yeah, it is.
00:20:14Why don't you just say it?
00:20:16He's rich, so he bangs me.
00:20:17So what?
00:20:18You know what?
00:20:19You can forget your stupid case
00:20:20because I didn't want to do it in the first place.
00:20:22Sophie.
00:20:25Let me get this straight.
00:20:27Are you a good lawyer?
00:20:28Or are you just somebody who knows how to choose?
00:20:30You can't take something to trial
00:20:31if you think you're going to lose.
00:20:32Well, I think a better person would stand up for the truth.
00:20:36Well, you got the wrong floor.
00:20:38This is the bad people floor.
00:20:40Good people around, too.
00:20:41You told me you were this close to making a case.
00:20:43I didn't know what she did.
00:20:44She went to a bar, just like Tommy.
00:20:46Yeah, and if Tommy came to me and said he was raped,
00:20:47I wouldn't take his case either.
00:20:48That's pretty cynical.
00:20:49Look, I don't know where you've been for the last 50 years,
00:20:52but this is not an easy thing to do.
00:20:53For me to win, I've got to get a virgin on that stand
00:20:56in a white dress with a halo over her head.
00:20:58You came to her.
00:20:59You held out your hand.
00:21:00And when she reached up, you pulled it back.
00:21:02Because the story changed.
00:21:03She was raped.
00:21:04We both know that.
00:21:07You know, it doesn't matter if she wins.
00:21:08She wants to fight this.
00:21:10And if we fight with her, she has a chance of getting over it.
00:21:12She has hope.
00:21:13And if we don't, she has nothing.
00:21:21Bring her back.
00:21:23Not if you don't try.
00:21:25Don't push me, Miss McKinley.
00:21:27If I'm going to do this,
00:21:27I don't need any more speeches out of you.
00:21:37You okay?
00:21:39I screwed up.
00:21:42He'll do it.
00:21:45If you want him to.
00:21:46I don't know what's the matter with me.
00:21:53You don't eat?
00:21:55Not today.
00:21:57You're one of those ulcer types, right?
00:21:58Everything is tied up inside, right?
00:22:01Not really.
00:22:03You keep your hands in fists.
00:22:05I do not.
00:22:06I saw you in the office.
00:22:07I thought you were going to pop him right in the jaw.
00:22:09I haven't told him yet.
00:22:15My father.
00:22:17Why not?
00:22:18Well, because he thinks the Bickleys are like God.
00:22:21He works 50 hours a day for no money.
00:22:24And he says we're lucky.
00:22:26But they take care of us.
00:22:28He takes care of you, Sophie.
00:22:31He doesn't know what I do.
00:22:33After my mom died, he just sort of stopped paying attention.
00:22:39So he falls asleep, and I crawl out a window.
00:22:42And he never knows.
00:22:45Do you want some help?
00:22:47Thanks anyway, but I kind of have to tell myself.
00:22:49We're not sure why she brought the charges.
00:23:17But her story doesn't hold up.
00:23:21We thought that you should take a look at these statements before things get messy.
00:23:26He doesn't read English.
00:23:28Read it for him.
00:23:47Papa?
00:23:55Papa?
00:24:02What?
00:24:08I should have forbidden the car.
00:24:10It wasn't the car.
00:24:13Sixteen.
00:24:14For what do you need a car?
00:24:16So I can study, Papa, to get to the library.
00:24:27Papa?
00:24:28Wait!
00:24:31What are you doing?
00:24:34What?
00:24:35No!
00:24:36No!
00:24:37Stop!
00:24:37That's fine!
00:24:38What are you doing?
00:24:39Stop it!
00:24:41Stop it!
00:24:43I need you to stop it!
00:24:44You let him touch you?
00:24:50No!
00:24:51That's not what happened!
00:24:52That's not what happened to me!
00:24:54Molly!
00:24:58Wake up!
00:25:00It's Joe Finn, Molly!
00:25:04Molly, are you in there?
00:25:07Molly!
00:25:10Molly, wake up!
00:25:11It's Joe Finn!
00:25:15We've got some trouble.
00:25:17Ten minutes after I filed, Bickley's lawyer shows up with depositions.
00:25:23Six people at the bar say that Sophie was with Tommy that night and she was coming on to him.
00:25:27Now, did you even ask her what happened?
00:25:29Of course I did.
00:25:30Why didn't you tell me?
00:25:31What do you think this is?
00:25:32A Disney movie?
00:25:34He beat her!
00:25:35You keep saying that, but it doesn't matter.
00:25:37Not if nobody believes her.
00:25:38We'll tell that to Sophie.
00:25:39No, you tell Sophie.
00:25:40And you tell her that she better start telling the truth.
00:25:42Because if they turn up one more lie, then that's it.
00:25:46You know what?
00:25:49I'm getting sick of you.
00:25:51Sick of you sitting up on your high horse.
00:25:52You said you would fight for her.
00:25:54That's right.
00:25:54Fight the most powerful family in this state.
00:25:57And if she lies again, that's the end.
00:25:59That's it.
00:26:00Ten years.
00:26:00My whole career.
00:26:01What about you?
00:26:02What do you lose?
00:26:03This isn't about me.
00:26:04Nothing.
00:26:04You don't lose a thing.
00:26:06Do you?
00:26:07I don't lose a thing.
00:26:37So what did you think?
00:26:52They wouldn't find out?
00:26:53I told you what happened.
00:26:54What you told me was that he was hitting on you.
00:26:56He was?
00:26:57You were kissing him in a public place.
00:26:59Oh, you think that's the same?
00:27:00You think it's like having sex?
00:27:01To some people it is, yes.
00:27:02I told him to back off.
00:27:04It doesn't matter.
00:27:05Oh, so it's my fault, right?
00:27:07You're going to make it look like it was your fault.
00:27:08What am I supposed to do?
00:27:09Go home, pretend like nothing happened, act like I'm fine?
00:27:11You can't lie.
00:27:12I didn't lie.
00:27:13And you cannot hide things.
00:27:15They're going to find out and they're going to use it against you.
00:27:20What?
00:27:20I took money.
00:27:24What do you mean?
00:27:27Just once, it was a joke.
00:27:29Some old guy, he says he wants some company and he'll give me money.
00:27:33I won't tell them that.
00:27:35If my father found out, it would kill him.
00:27:37I'll lie if they ask.
00:27:38Why do you do this?
00:27:40Don't start with me.
00:27:41This is not good for you, Sophie.
00:27:42Don't judge me.
00:27:43I'm not judging you.
00:27:44Some kind of pathetic kid, right?
00:27:45A real loser.
00:27:46No.
00:27:47You know, just because you wear blue skirts all the time and ugly shoes and no makeup
00:27:51and you think that's how it's supposed to be.
00:27:52What about Tommy?
00:27:54Did he give you something?
00:27:56What do you think?
00:27:57I think if he did, you better tell me now.
00:27:59Yeah, he gave me a trust fund.
00:28:00That's why I'm having such a great time right now.
00:28:02I'm going to finish with these.
00:28:27Molly McKinley, Lee Keating, I represent the Bickley family.
00:28:32I was hoping we could have a nice little chat.
00:28:36Why would we want to do that?
00:28:38The Bickley family is very important to this community.
00:28:41I thought that maybe we should have a reasonable discussion before things get carried away.
00:28:45Doesn't matter what I have to say.
00:28:47I'm not the one that was raped.
00:28:49There's obviously been some confusion.
00:28:52Well, if you're confused, you should be talking to Tommy.
00:28:54Tommy's very upset.
00:28:56He was under the impression that Sophie liked him.
00:28:58What do you want?
00:28:59You want her to back off?
00:29:00You want her to change her mind?
00:29:01Sophie's a child.
00:29:03I don't think she really knows what's going to happen if she goes through with this.
00:29:06Is that a threat, Mr. Keating?
00:29:08It's a fact.
00:29:09She's been making some outlandish accusations.
00:29:12Well, the fact is that my client was raped and you can push all you want.
00:29:16That's not going to change.
00:29:17Why don't you wake up, Ms. McKinley?
00:29:19She lied from the time she first opened her mouth.
00:29:23It's a subpoena.
00:29:23I need to look at her files.
00:29:26Session notes, appointment logs, incident reports.
00:29:30I have to verify her story.
00:29:32Now, you can give me those tonight or you can give them to me tomorrow morning in court.
00:29:36I'm not giving you anything.
00:29:38You have no choice.
00:29:39If Sophie persists in bringing charges, those records are mine.
00:29:44Good day, Ms. McKinley.
00:29:45They want my files.
00:29:56So?
00:29:57Those files are my property.
00:29:59They can't just take them away.
00:30:00Well, Sophie accused a man of rape.
00:30:02The Constitution says he's got a right to defend himself.
00:30:04They can't take your files?
00:30:05Well, certain relationships have been protected.
00:30:07What relationships?
00:30:08Doctors, lawyers.
00:30:09Therapists.
00:30:09Licensed therapists.
00:30:11Sophie gave me confidential information the same way she would talk to a therapist.
00:30:14It's the same thing.
00:30:15What information?
00:30:16What do you mean?
00:30:17You hiding something?
00:30:18No.
00:30:18Well, then there shouldn't be any trouble.
00:30:19You just give them the files.
00:30:20Those are private conversations.
00:30:23If there's some reason why you can't turn them over, then you better let me know what it is.
00:30:27I am trying to make a place where Sophie can feel safe, where she can talk and not have to pay for it.
00:30:32Well, if she's not hiding anything, she won't have to pay.
00:30:34Other people have this right.
00:30:36If she could afford a psychiatrist, we wouldn't even be having this discussion.
00:30:39Look, you can't keep those files.
00:30:44Thanks for the advice.
00:30:45It's against the law.
00:30:48It's not a very good law, is it?
00:31:03You're late.
00:31:04Don't start.
00:31:05Mr. DeFazio called three times already.
00:31:08He says you're going to pay the rent today.
00:31:09I said tomorrow.
00:31:12You missed your 10.30.
00:31:15Tell me that was a joke.
00:31:17She left something for you in your office.
00:31:18I thought you were mad.
00:31:28Mad?
00:31:29About the money.
00:31:32Sophie, no.
00:31:34You know, you got to water that thing.
00:31:37It won't just grow by itself.
00:31:38I didn't want this job.
00:31:49I thought I was going to play hockey.
00:31:51That's how I got to college.
00:31:52Scholarship.
00:31:52Why'd you stop?
00:31:55Messed up my knees.
00:31:57They kept telling me to quit, but I just couldn't do it.
00:32:04I scheduled you a hearing tomorrow morning.
00:32:06You need a lawyer.
00:32:09I thought you were the lawyer.
00:32:10Well, for the state, I can't represent the Rape Crisis Center.
00:32:13Well, I can't pay a lawyer.
00:32:15I know somebody.
00:32:20Who is this guy?
00:32:21Why are you whispering?
00:32:24Why would somebody who lives here want to take this case?
00:32:26It's a labor of love.
00:32:28Love of what?
00:32:29Joey Finn.
00:32:33Cute as he ever was.
00:32:34You said I would do it for free?
00:32:40Well, not exactly free.
00:32:42How exactly not?
00:32:43You get to spend time with me.
00:32:45All the right lines, every time.
00:32:48You know, I really just need you to explain it to the judge.
00:32:50You're telling me that I have 14 hours to prepare a case that has no foundation in the law.
00:32:55Since when did you worry about the law?
00:32:58This man could talk a nun into bed.
00:33:01I wouldn't want to.
00:33:03Excuse me.
00:33:03Do you have a restroom?
00:33:06Right that way.
00:33:06I wouldn't want to.
00:33:07You're saying, Oh.
00:33:11I 카메라 says it works.
00:33:25I've said it's not how soon they become my son.
00:33:26I do not want to.
00:33:26I do not want to.
00:33:27I affine it.
00:33:27I'll give a minute to try a few more hours.
00:33:28What can I do?
00:33:29I do not want to.
00:33:29Why?
00:33:29I do not want to.
00:33:30I you're chyba.
00:33:30I know I'm onceenne in my dog.
00:33:32I am.
00:33:32I know I'm going to try and get it.
00:33:33I won't want to.
00:33:33he's the only person i ever met who could date three women at the same time
00:33:43and get away with it let's change the law
00:33:48yes what do you think
00:33:52and then she tells me she wants me to look less severe so the judge will know i care about sophie
00:33:59hmm i thought you were doing it for him who that lawyer guy finn i'd dress up if i were you
00:34:08that's for sophie the controversy began two days ago when the defense attorney subpoenaed the victim's
00:34:14why don't you go like that the director of the center a former sister of mercy decided to put
00:34:19her conscience before the court order in a formal statement she declared the subpoena a violation
00:34:24of her client's right to privacy and refused to surrender the files the judge has called
00:34:29his defiance delinquent and promises immediate reprisal
00:34:33molly molly wake up
00:34:38you lied to me i didn't lie to you you said it was safe nobody finds out sophie it's just you and me
00:34:46it is safe right here why should i believe you i trusted you i told you everything i didn't know
00:34:54you were a nun there's nothing to do with you sat there you sat there thinking how cheap i was and
00:34:59i was thinking maybe you're right maybe there's something wrong with me sophie i never said that
00:35:02why don't you burn it they cannot take the files what are you gonna do say no venus light candles for me
00:35:10okay fine you don't trust me burn it you burn it go on
00:35:15a nun what kind of nun sister of mercy i knew it that's the kind that doesn't talk right no
00:35:25now just a minute though you got married right i mean with a wedding dress a ring shut up what will
00:35:31the court please ride let me try to understand the problem here three days ago i issued a subpoena to
00:35:39your client requesting certain records be presented to this court are we in agreement about that yes
00:35:45your honor and she has refused to do it that's correct i trust you have informed her she is in
00:35:51content her position is that the information is privileged and not relevant to the defense
00:35:55how are we to make a decision as to relevance miss hayes if we don't know what those files contain
00:36:02section six of the healthcare confidentiality act indicates records may not be released without the
00:36:07consent of the patient are you saying your client is a healthcare provider your honor i object does
00:36:13she meet the definition the statute doesn't specify is she a doctor does she have a license the language
00:36:20is quite broad paragraph three explicitly defines my client's work requires privacy and confidentiality
00:36:27they are both constitutionally protected miss hayes today is my birthday
00:36:33i hope it's not going to get any worse
00:36:39they're doing that hearing said it on the news
00:36:47i was thinking maybe i should go
00:36:51what kind of records do you keep at the center names phone numbers um after each session i write a
00:36:58couple of sentences about what happened is it your policy to show those notes to other people
00:37:03outside the center no why not our clients come to us in in confidence many of them are ashamed about
00:37:09what happened what if a client said it was okay i'd advise her not to why she doesn't talk to me the
00:37:18same way she would talk to you people express doubts in therapy what kind of doubts maybe it was her fault
00:37:27something she wore something she said i mean she might even say that the man who assaulted her looked too
00:37:32short in the lineup because she isn't sure no because when he raped her he seemed huge and her statement
00:37:39taken out of context could could make it sound like like she isn't certain when she is
00:37:43no more questions your honor
00:37:50are you going to be home for dinner i waited two hours last night you can at least tell me that
00:38:03it's uh your contention miss mckinley that the information contained in these documents should
00:38:11be withheld from the defense i feel it should be protected yes what if a client told you she wasn't
00:38:17sure who raped her but she was uh pressing charges anyway would you protect that information it wouldn't
00:38:23happen but if it did rape victims don't just randomly pick someone to prosecute they want justice not
00:38:30revenge just answer the question what if you knew that the man she accused was innocent
00:38:36you're distorting the issue your honor this is completely hypothetical i want to hear it
00:38:41answer the question please
00:38:47if i knew that a client of mine had deliberately accused the wrong person i would step forward
00:38:53what if you just suspected if you saw inconsistencies if you thought maybe she's lying to me
00:38:59i told you my clients do not lie but you just said they get confused i mean first he's tall and short
00:39:06if they're confused it'll come out in testimony the issue here is confidentiality people have a right
00:39:12to a private conversation with a counselor and who's to decide if that conversation is relevant to the
00:39:18defense you are the jury
00:39:26the rape crisis center is clearly of great benefit to the women who come to you for help
00:39:32your passion in this cause is commendable but we are governed by law not passion we are not free in
00:39:38this country to break the law for a personal cause this defendant has a right to the records of the
00:39:45center as much as he has a right to the records of the police department or the emergency room at a
00:39:49hospital i direct that they be produced immediately your honor it's not the same
00:39:54miss hayes please sit down i haven't finished
00:39:59if the statute was meant to protect rape crisis centers it would have said so excuse me molly your
00:40:05honor this girl was raped she's not conspiring with me she's trying to get her life back your honor is
00:40:10completely out of line the center is the only place she feels safe how how can i help her get
00:40:15well if everything she says to me can be used against her by the defense miss mckinley if you
00:40:19prevail upon me to consider the facts then you must abide by the decision i make i can't
00:40:28you refuse to surrender the records yes
00:40:33then i'm afraid i shall have to incarcerate you you will be taken to the women's reformatory
00:40:38you can't sentence her indefinitely she has the keys to the cell in her own pocket miss hayes
00:40:43your honor this is unconscionable objection noted we are adjourned
00:40:59i'm a lawyer not her conscience
00:41:10how long does that take months we can push it through you want her in jail is that what you want
00:41:26i'm her lawyer not her conscience i'll be fine you know what it's like inside there's one prison
00:41:33for women in this state it's got drug addicts killers women who keep razor blades under their
00:41:36tongues just in case made a decision joey i think we should support it you support it but you've made
00:41:43your point okay eight months from now when you're still inside here nobody's going to remember what
00:41:47that point was sophie's not a point she's a person and so are you it's not a sin to change your mind
00:41:54you think it's my fault is it go to hell why don't you tell me tell you what what you told molly
00:42:12that's what you're afraid of isn't it maybe it's none of your business are you hiding something what
00:42:16do you think what do you think i hope not because she's in a lot of trouble
00:42:25you'll get one
00:42:42holy moly look what just blew in from kansas okay ladies let's go
00:42:55do you lose something no
00:43:11you
00:43:16don't push it gets better down the road
00:43:25turn around
00:43:50open your mouth wide
00:43:58take your clothes off
00:44:00my clothes you want it easy or hard
00:44:10it's been almost two weeks since molly mckinley the former sister of mercy enters the woman's
00:44:15correctional facility in spite of protests from human rights organizations and local women's
00:44:21group judge boland shows no sign of reversing his decision the woman's lawyer has applied several
00:44:26times for protective custody which has been
00:44:31turn it off
00:44:33the family has applied excessive financial and political
00:44:37pressure can i help you excuse me miss do you have a minute this is cold you know what i'm talking to
00:44:44someone right now wait your turn or take it to the kitchen yourself
00:44:46i've got a daughter your age 16
00:44:57not quite so feisty
00:45:00must be hard on you all the commotion
00:45:0314 days 14 days in jail 12 days
00:45:09it's a long time to spend a place like that
00:45:11what do you want you blame yourself right you're the reason she's in there it's a big responsibility
00:45:24you could do something it's none of your business those records belong to you
00:45:29so if you turn them over they'd have to let her go it's your choice not hers that's what she's fighting
00:45:39for right so you can decide
00:45:59you got a problem no
00:46:24you had a problem with me what do you want
00:46:27there's a kid in visiting says she's your daughter
00:46:36what happened
00:46:39immaculate conception
00:46:41you shouldn't have come
00:46:59why because you don't want to see me because this isn't a good place for you to be
00:47:02and it's not a good place for you either is it i'm fine you don't look fine
00:47:10well who are you gonna believe you or me
00:47:13you should just give them the file it's not that important
00:47:16i think it is
00:47:21i brought you something
00:47:23my dad makes them sometimes when my mom was alive he said that they look like her
00:47:31and now it's her spirit watching over us he says what you do is is you put her over your bed
00:47:38at night so she can stop by and make sure you're all right
00:47:42it's beautiful i talk to her sometimes ask her to help out with things i usually go to the cemetery but
00:47:53i think you can broadcast from here under the circumstances i don't think she'd mind
00:47:58i'm sorry about this
00:48:06i know
00:48:20i need to talk to you
00:48:23i went to see her today in the jail
00:48:25they're saying they'll keep her there unless she gives them the records
00:48:32the thing is it's my fault
00:48:38i told her things secrets i didn't want you to be ashamed of me
00:48:44did you hear what i said
00:48:55why do you keep ignoring me
00:48:58i'm trying to talk to you i'm trying to tell you something
00:49:00i went out sometimes at night i got dressed up i went to bars
00:49:08i'm not what you think i am
00:49:10i am not a whore
00:49:11pensa a tua madre
00:49:12english
00:49:16he raped me
00:49:19you know why she's in jail
00:49:21well because of you because i was afraid of hurting you
00:49:39i'm sofi
00:49:49damadio
00:49:51i'm sorry to bother you
00:49:55they said the records are mine
00:49:58technically
00:49:58i want to give them to you
00:50:15i can't do this
00:50:16it's her right
00:50:17those were my records
00:50:18your sofa's records
00:50:19my apartment and what gives you the right to go in there without my permission
00:50:22what did you break in
00:50:23not exactly
00:50:24yeah well i could sue you for that
00:50:26it's her choice molly
00:50:27she is 16 years old
00:50:28what the hell does she know
00:50:29no you better get this under control
00:50:31don't you tell me how to act
00:50:32not you
00:50:42she was a little surprised
00:50:45what kind of a stunt was that
00:50:46what do you mean
00:50:47we agreed
00:50:48i changed my mind
00:50:50no you didn't change your mind
00:50:51they changed your mind
00:50:52who did
00:50:53who's they
00:50:54the bickleys your father mr finn
00:50:56you said i should tell the truth
00:50:57not your whole life story
00:50:58so i did
00:50:59so what i didn't rape anybody i shouldn't be ashamed
00:51:02this isn't about shame there are issues
00:51:04what issues
00:51:04privacy
00:51:05my privacy isn't that what you said i decide
00:51:07you want to stay in jail forever right
00:51:09all you care about is your stupid issues
00:51:11that is not true
00:51:12it is
00:51:13saint molly saves the day
00:51:14but fine you want to give him those records you just give him those records
00:51:17but don't expect me to pick up the pieces because i can't
00:51:20i cannot do it
00:51:24how many people need to find you
00:51:30for the times
00:51:32you know what you eat
00:51:33must say
00:51:35what you want to do
00:51:35that's what you want to do
00:51:37what you want to do
00:51:37what you want to do
00:51:38that's what you want to do
00:51:39that's how you want to do
00:51:41you'll be alone
00:51:41you're punishing me right what do you mean my mother used to do it starve and suffer
00:51:59i'm not hungry listen i read the files i don't think they're so bad if keating finds out that
00:52:08sophie took money so what it's not admissible it has nothing to do with the rape they'll use it
00:52:13anyway so we moved to strike it's a trick you know that the jury hears they're not gonna forget
00:52:19fine so we come at it a different way let him call her a floozy a tramp whatever he wants and then i
00:52:24put you up on the stand and i make it clear to the jury that you really know sophie you know what
00:52:29really happened won't work ex-none sister of mercy for god's sake what could be better than that
00:52:34joe she said that if anybody ever found out about this it would destroy her now she told me i wrote
00:52:40it down and they're going to use it against her she's a tough kid maybe she's not
00:52:45i used to teach before i left the convent a student of mine
00:52:55it's a girl she came to me and she told me that a boy forced her to have sex
00:53:01she said she was fine and i let her go and uh she killed herself that night this is not the same
00:53:10thing you don't know if she's fine she doesn't even know but you can't quit just because you're
00:53:15afraid i can't sit there and watch them break her down please don't don't go on with this case
00:53:20just drop it it's not too late i can't why i promised a friend of mine okay wasn't a friend
00:53:28at first but then she said something that kind of got to me she said the only thing that really
00:53:33matters is sophie and if we fight for her and that's all she needs
00:53:40is that she needs to be able to do it i want to do it i want to do it i want to do it i want to do it
00:53:55I don't know.
00:54:25I don't know.
00:54:55I don't know.
00:55:25It hit me, and I skidded off the road.
00:55:28He pulled in front of me and got out.
00:55:31I said, what the hell's the matter with you?
00:55:33And he said he was tired of me playing games.
00:55:37He must have hit me because I was bleeding.
00:55:39What was he doing?
00:55:42Tearing my underwear, pulling it off.
00:55:44Did you tell him to stop?
00:55:46I kicked him.
00:55:48I leaned on the horn.
00:55:49I kept reaching for the light.
00:55:50I thought if somebody could see...
00:55:53What happened?
00:55:55I crawled in the back seat.
00:55:56He followed me.
00:56:00That's all, Your Honor.
00:56:01Top student, editor of a law review.
00:56:07I have to say that Tommy Binkley I know couldn't do something like this.
00:56:10If he didn't do it, why accuse him?
00:56:12People are hungry for attention.
00:56:14A big trial like this, it says you belong somehow.
00:56:17The system recognizes you.
00:56:19You count.
00:56:19You think she's lying?
00:56:20I don't think her story holds up.
00:56:22Why didn't you tell anyone you were raped?
00:56:25Because I thought I could get in trouble.
00:56:27With whom?
00:56:28With the police.
00:56:28I had a fake ID.
00:56:30With your father?
00:56:33Maybe.
00:56:34Is that why you lied?
00:56:35I didn't lie.
00:56:36You gave him the wrong name?
00:56:37Wrong age?
00:56:39You claimed you were in the car alone?
00:56:41Sounds like a lie to me.
00:56:42Your Honor.
00:56:43Did your father know that you went to the bars?
00:56:46No.
00:56:47Did he know you were sexually active?
00:56:49No.
00:56:49Did he know that you had taken money for sex?
00:56:52Objection.
00:56:53Sustained.
00:56:54Jury will disregard that question.
00:56:56You know better than that, Mr. Keating.
00:56:59You didn't want your father to know, did you?
00:57:02What you were doing that night.
00:57:03That's right.
00:57:05What made you change your mind?
00:57:08Didn't you imagine your father would be less upset if he thought you were raped?
00:57:11Than if he thought you were having sex?
00:57:13No.
00:57:14That's what you told Molly McKinley.
00:57:16I never said that.
00:57:17You said it would kill your father if he knew.
00:57:19Not about sex.
00:57:21About what?
00:57:31That I took money.
00:57:34Order.
00:57:35Order.
00:57:35So, you didn't want your father to know that you had taken money for sex, and you told
00:57:45Molly McKinley that you would lie if necessary to hide that problem.
00:57:49Isn't that true?
00:57:50I thought I would lie.
00:57:54I changed my mind.
00:57:56No further questions.
00:57:57The defense calls Thomas Franklin McKinley, the third.
00:58:04We were at the bar.
00:58:06Things were pretty intense.
00:58:09She said we should go to Gilliam's Pond.
00:58:12She said I should follow her because she had a bigger car.
00:58:16So we drove to the pond.
00:58:18We parked.
00:58:20I got in.
00:58:21That's it?
00:58:21We had sex.
00:58:23Was it consensual?
00:58:25Yes.
00:58:26No further questions.
00:58:28Where did you first meet Sophie DiMario?
00:58:30Bigley Hospital, March 24th of this year.
00:58:33Why were you there?
00:58:34I was there to help her through an evidentiary exam.
00:58:37The resident said she'd been raped.
00:58:39Objection?
00:58:41Miss McKinley, the resident will testify as to his own opinion.
00:58:44You can't do it for him.
00:58:46When you got to the hospital, how did Sophie look to you?
00:58:50She had a cut on her head.
00:58:51There was a lot of blood and she seemed to be in shock.
00:58:54Did she tell you what happened?
00:58:56I asked her if someone had hurt her and she nodded.
00:58:59The next day she came to my office and said she'd been raped.
00:59:02Do you believe she was raped?
00:59:04Her belief isn't relevant.
00:59:05I'll allow it.
00:59:07Go ahead.
00:59:10Yes, I do.
00:59:12No further questions.
00:59:15When you first met Sophie, what name did she give you?
00:59:22She didn't give me her name.
00:59:24What name did you write on this form?
00:59:26Teresa Silvio.
00:59:28This form also says she's 23.
00:59:31Is she 23?
00:59:33No.
00:59:35She gave you the wrong name, the wrong age,
00:59:39but when she told you that she was raped, you believed her.
00:59:41Yes, I did.
00:59:42And so did the police and the doctors and the man who found her bleeding on the side of the road.
00:59:46Thank you, Ms. McKinley.
00:59:49This note here, what does it say?
00:59:53You're taking this out of context.
00:59:55Can you read it aloud for me, please?
00:59:57No prior physical contact.
01:00:00Did you write that?
01:00:01Yes, I did.
01:00:02Six witnesses saw Sophie making out with Tommy in the bar that night.
01:00:07Now, when she told you that she was raped, did she tell you that?
01:00:12She was telling the story in pieces.
01:00:13No prior physical contact.
01:00:17Did she say that?
01:00:18No.
01:00:19You wrote it down.
01:00:21I was making an assumption.
01:00:22She was terrified.
01:00:23She didn't want to talk to me in the beginning at all.
01:00:25You said that she told you what happened and you believed her.
01:00:28I believed she was raped, yes.
01:00:30Something in the margin here.
01:00:37What is it?
01:00:39A little mark.
01:00:44Answer the question, please.
01:00:47It's a question mark.
01:00:48Question mark.
01:00:49Did you make that mark?
01:00:51Yes.
01:00:52What does it mean?
01:00:54She was afraid that...
01:00:55Afraid or not, you thought she was lying.
01:00:58Objection.
01:00:58Sophie never lied about being raped.
01:01:00From the day I met her, that story didn't change.
01:01:03Mrs. McKinley, you didn't believe her.
01:01:05What did you think she was lying to you about?
01:01:07Where she was raped?
01:01:08How she was raped?
01:01:09Who raped her?
01:01:10If she was raped?
01:01:11Your Honor?
01:01:16No further questions.
01:01:17No further questions.
01:01:17Whatever.
01:01:19No further questions.
01:01:21No further questions.
01:01:30Think oh!
01:01:36What did you see?
01:01:38Jacob!
01:01:39Hey!
01:01:39Paul!
01:01:44Who stuck?
01:01:45You left pretty fast.
01:02:13I'm pretty busy.
01:02:15I can see.
01:02:19I keep trying to apologize.
01:02:23I keep trying to tell myself that you were right.
01:02:27I pushed too hard.
01:02:28That I shouldn't have put you on the stand.
01:02:31Or I should have just dropped the case.
01:02:34But you know something? I'm not sorry.
01:02:37I'm sorry I didn't do better, but I'm not sorry I tried.
01:02:41You didn't hurt Sophie, Molly.
01:02:45They did.
01:02:47You gotta stop blaming yourself and just get back in the game.
01:02:51Get back in the game.
01:02:53I'm sorry.
01:02:55I'm sorry.
01:02:57I'm sorry.
01:02:59I'm sorry.
01:03:01I'm sorry.
01:03:03I'm sorry.
01:03:05I'm sorry.
01:03:07I'm sorry.
01:03:09I'm sorry.
01:03:11I'm sorry.
01:03:13I'm sorry.
01:03:15I'm sorry.
01:03:17I'm sorry.
01:03:19I'm sorry.
01:03:21I'm sorry.
01:03:23I'm sorry, Molly.
01:03:33I'm sorry.
01:03:39I'm sorry.
01:03:41I'm sorry.
01:03:43It's just...
01:04:13Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.
01:04:41It's been two years since my last confession.
01:04:45What are your sins?
01:04:48I let someone die.
01:04:52Go on.
01:04:55Two years ago, when I was teaching, she came to me and she was in pain.
01:05:01I didn't listen carefully to what she was saying.
01:05:04I sent her away.
01:05:06How did you sin?
01:05:08I didn't help her.
01:05:09I didn't want her to depend on me.
01:05:14That's not a sin, Molly.
01:05:17She killed herself.
01:05:19You think it was your fault?
01:05:24I hurt people, Father.
01:05:27Doesn't matter what I do, I hurt them.
01:05:30Every day I wake up with my hands in fists and I push people away.
01:05:34What she chose to do is between her and God.
01:05:40I doubt it was because of you.
01:05:43I'm afraid.
01:05:46What did she teach you, Molly?
01:05:48How can you live differently because of her?
01:05:50I don't know.
01:05:51I think you do.
01:05:53If it troubles you somewhere in your heart, you do.
01:05:57Mr. DiMario, I'm Molly McKinley.
01:06:12I'm looking for Sophie.
01:06:14She go.
01:06:16What do you mean?
01:06:16The neighbor, she says she sees Sophie in the road.
01:06:20She has her bag with her.
01:06:22She get into a truck.
01:06:23I go to the police, but they no help.
01:06:27I don't know where else to go.
01:06:31She has no mother.
01:06:33I hear her at night, in and out, all night long.
01:06:37I stay awake.
01:06:38I want to say something.
01:06:41I never do.
01:06:43I think maybe I lose her, too.
01:06:46You know Sophie.
01:06:48You know where she go.
01:06:50Please, you help me.
01:06:52It's 1.15 W.R.I.C. Richmond in the first few hours of a new day.
01:06:59Still awake?
01:07:00You got some troubles?
01:07:01No one to talk to?
01:07:02Well, Ira's here.
01:07:03And all ears.
01:07:04So why don't you pick up the phone and give the bad dream to me?
01:07:08Line one, we've got Bob G. from Baltimore.
01:07:10Is that right?
01:07:11I took something.
01:07:12Took something?
01:07:13What do you mean?
01:07:14You mean you're a thief?
01:07:16It was just sitting there on the counter.
01:07:18Nobody was looking.
01:07:19Took what?
01:07:20Stereo?
01:07:21Piano?
01:07:21Color TV?
01:07:22A wallet?
01:07:24A wallet?
01:07:25Yeah.
01:07:26So, why are you calling me?
01:07:29I don't know.
01:07:30You want to give it back?
01:07:32No.
01:07:33Something's troubling you, man.
01:07:35That's why you picked up the phone.
01:07:37Bob?
01:07:38You still with me?
01:07:40Yeah.
01:07:40Maybe you should tell somebody.
01:08:04I'm telling you.
01:08:06I'm going to hang up, Bob.
01:08:09Then what?
01:08:10I'll call again.
01:08:10I'll call again.
01:08:10I'll call again.
01:08:15Bye.
01:08:31Bye.
01:08:32Bye.
01:08:34Bye.
01:08:35Bye.
01:08:35Bye.
01:08:35Bye.
01:08:36Bye.
01:08:36Bye.
01:08:37Bye.
01:08:38Somebody said they saw you on the highway getting into a truck.
01:08:54I changed my mind.
01:09:00She was very sick, you know, before she died.
01:09:06What?
01:09:06Nothing.
01:09:09I'm not drunk.
01:09:10I didn't say you were.
01:09:16What are you doing?
01:09:18Leaving.
01:09:19And where will you go?
01:09:20I don't know. You don't always have to know everything before you do it.
01:09:23You have a family, Sophie.
01:09:24Oh, right.
01:09:25He's very worried.
01:09:26Because he doesn't know how to make breakfast.
01:09:29Because he loves you.
01:09:30He wants me to be like she was.
01:09:32No, he doesn't.
01:09:33What do you know? You're a nun.
01:09:34I'm not a nun.
01:09:35Well, you act like one.
01:09:36And what's that supposed to mean?
01:09:37You're a statue. Nothing touches you.
01:09:39All right, you have a right to be mad.
01:09:41I'm not mad. I'd have to like you for that.
01:09:44And I don't.
01:09:45Okay.
01:09:45I tried.
01:09:46I know you did.
01:09:47I tried.
01:09:48I wasn't very nice to you.
01:09:56It doesn't matter.
01:09:58You want to know why?
01:10:00Because I'm afraid of things and people.
01:10:03Everybody.
01:10:03I don't care.
01:10:04Well, I do.
01:10:05So you listen to me.
01:10:06I have never gotten close to anybody.
01:10:10I worry all the time.
01:10:11I don't know what to say or I'm going to say the wrong thing.
01:10:13And usually I do say the wrong thing or nothing at all.
01:10:16That's even worse.
01:10:18And I couldn't face it.
01:10:19So I ran away.
01:10:21And I gave myself to God.
01:10:23I wasn't good, Sophia.
01:10:26I was ashamed.
01:10:29I didn't think I deserved a life.
01:10:34Please come home.
01:10:37Why?
01:10:38Because I don't want you to waste all the time that I did.
01:10:44Please.
01:10:53He used to wait up for my mother.
01:11:04Then she worked at night.
01:11:07He'd just sit there with the light on until she came home.
01:11:12He wanted to make sure she was safe.
01:11:23What are you doing here?
01:11:48Mom, I didn't want to miss you.
01:11:50Right after he left, this guy came by.
01:11:54He says he's a defense attorney.
01:11:57He wants to see the records on Jimena Garcia.
01:12:00Oh, I don't believe this.
01:12:01It's a subpoena.
01:12:02It's never going to end, is it?
01:12:04He said he wants to see the files tonight.
01:12:08Did you do it?
01:12:09Hey.
01:12:14He says if you don't turn them over, they'll throw you in jail.
01:12:18This is just going to keep happening, huh, Molly?
01:12:20On March 23rd of this year, Sophie DiMario went to a bar called Johnny B's, just outside Richmond.
01:12:33By her own admission, this is something that she did quite frequently.
01:12:36Using a counterfeit license, driving an unregistered vehicle, she went there to pick up guys.
01:12:42Sophie was in the bar by her choice that night, and she met Tommy Bickley.
01:12:50She let Tommy kiss her.
01:12:52She let Tommy buy her beer.
01:12:56Six witnesses saw Sophie that night having a very good time.
01:13:01Now Sophie says that Tommy raped her.
01:13:04Tommy denies this.
01:13:06You have a decision to make.
01:13:09You have to ask yourself, which of them is telling me the truth?
01:13:14And as you're making that decision, remember this.
01:13:17Sophie lied.
01:13:18She lied to the police when they first met her.
01:13:23She lied to the doctors at the hospital.
01:13:26She lied to her rape crisis counselor.
01:13:29She lied to her father every time she went to that bar.
01:13:34And after she claimed she was raped, she lied again as to how and what happened.
01:13:41Now Sophie has said that Tommy forced her to have sex.
01:13:47I can imagine another scenario.
01:13:51Sophie had sex willingly.
01:13:54Tommy went home.
01:13:55George Gillum found Sophie half naked, too drunk to drive, and called the police.
01:14:01And now Sophie had a real problem.
01:14:06How was she going to explain all of this to her father?
01:14:09A sweet old man who had no idea of the kind of life Sophie had been leading.
01:14:17There was no case for conviction.
01:14:20There was just a question mark at the end of her testimony.
01:14:25You can't but have a doubt, a reasonable doubt,
01:14:29the same doubt that Molly McKinley had when Sophie first told her this story.
01:14:33And if Sophie lied so many times to protect herself,
01:14:38maybe she's lying now.
01:14:41If Sophie was mugged, or robbed, or beaten,
01:14:56would you be asking yourself so earnestly
01:14:59whether or not she has a tendency to lie about things?
01:15:02I mean, if you found her bleeding on the sidewalk
01:15:04and she told you that somebody hit her,
01:15:07would you feel the need to examine the records of her therapy sessions?
01:15:11Would you think that she'd hit herself?
01:15:15Sophie lied.
01:15:17But she didn't lie about the cut on her head,
01:15:20the scratches on her back,
01:15:22the torn shirt, torn underpants.
01:15:24She wasn't lying when she leaned on the horn
01:15:26and woke George Gillum in the middle of the night.
01:15:28She lied after she was raped because she was afraid.
01:15:32She was afraid that if she told the truth, she'd be punished for it.
01:15:34She would be disbelieved.
01:15:36She would be penalized because she's a little wild.
01:15:39And she was right.
01:15:42The defense has exposed her most private conversations to you.
01:15:48They've unpacked her past,
01:15:49mistakes,
01:15:52her self-doubts,
01:15:54every indiscretion held up to you
01:15:56as proof that she wasn't raped.
01:15:58Now, let me tell you something about rape.
01:16:01It never takes place out in the open in front of a TV camera.
01:16:04It happens in the dark where nobody can see.
01:16:08And so it comes down to a choice.
01:16:10Which one of these two people do you believe?
01:16:13Now, the problem is,
01:16:15we can't expose the rapist the way we can expose the victim.
01:16:18I can't bring Tommy Bickley's therapy sessions,
01:16:21private confessions into this courtroom.
01:16:24The law protects him against that kind of an attack.
01:16:26So the only thing that you can do
01:16:27is look at the facts
01:16:29and ask yourself,
01:16:31is Tommy telling the truth?
01:16:32What about the dent in Sophie's fender?
01:16:34What about the stitches in her head?
01:16:36What about the emergency room report
01:16:38that lists her condition as victim of assault?
01:16:41Somebody hurt Sophie that night.
01:16:44I mean, there were only two people there,
01:16:45Sophie and Tommy.
01:16:46Which one of them is most likely to tell you
01:16:48what really happened?
01:16:50Tommy Bickley has been accused of rape.
01:16:53How reliable is he?
01:16:56Ask yourself.
01:16:57Could he get up on that stand and tell the truth?
01:16:59In front of his family, friends,
01:17:01in front of a judge, in front of a jury?
01:17:03Could he possibly get up there
01:17:04and tell the simple truth?
01:17:05Say, I did it.
01:17:07On the night of March 23rd, 1995,
01:17:10I, Thomas Bickley, ran Sophie DiMaggio off the road
01:17:12and I raped her!
01:17:13And I am guilty!
01:17:16You gave her something today.
01:17:40You took it away and you gave it back.
01:17:42Chinese?
01:17:49The only argument I can make
01:17:50is the same one I made before.
01:17:52You're a health care provider.
01:17:53Won't fly.
01:17:54It's a different judge.
01:17:55They all read the same law books, Molly.
01:17:57You have a hearing at 3 o'clock.
01:17:58We can't do anything by then.
01:18:01You have two choices.
01:18:03Give them Garcia's files
01:18:04or go back to jail.
01:18:05And what happens when they subpoena
01:18:06the next set of records?
01:18:07Who goes to jail for that?
01:18:08Oh, why do I even keep these files?
01:18:10If I didn't have them,
01:18:11they couldn't take them away.
01:18:13Molly.
01:18:19Jury's in.
01:18:20Two hours, that's it?
01:18:21Mr. Foreman.
01:18:27In the case of the state
01:18:28versus Thomas Franklin Bickley III,
01:18:30charging him
01:18:31on count one
01:18:33of first-degree rape,
01:18:34have you agreed upon a verdict?
01:18:36We have.
01:18:38Would the defendant please rise?
01:18:40Do you find the defendant guilty
01:18:44or not guilty?
01:18:46Guilty.
01:19:03Don't do it, Molly.
01:19:05I don't have to give them anything,
01:19:07not if it doesn't exist.
01:19:08I can't advise you to do this.
01:19:10Am I right?
01:19:10You're crazy.
01:19:11Okay, but am I right?
01:19:12You're never right.
01:19:16Bickley, how do you feel
01:19:16about what happened today?
01:19:17I think justice was served.
01:19:19What do you think?
01:19:19I think it's time to go home.
01:19:21What about the Garcia case?
01:19:22Are you prepared to go to jail again?
01:19:23If I have to.
01:19:36Quite a victory.
01:19:40You could have some trouble
01:19:41at the center.
01:19:44What kind of trouble?
01:19:46A lot of people don't approve
01:19:47of what you're doing.
01:19:49They find your tactics
01:19:50a bit extreme.
01:19:53Stick around, Mr. Keating.
01:19:55You ain't seen nothing yet.
01:19:57Go.
01:19:58Susan Ann, 112 86.
01:20:00You got it.
01:20:02Next.
01:20:02Arviter, 5588.
01:20:04Yep.
01:20:05Colleen Ball, 6685.
01:20:07Mary Ball, Sari, 412.
01:20:10Kathleen Mason, 5887.
01:20:12Elizabeth Morris, 7493.
01:20:15Hiroko Sakura, 1194.
01:20:18Margaret Salvia, 12692.
01:20:20Yep.
01:20:21Catalina Ruta, 61390.
01:20:23Yep.
01:20:24Catalina Ruta, 71088.
01:20:26Bingo.
01:20:27I heard you were having a party.
01:20:28I didn't want to miss it.
01:20:29Where did you get this?
01:20:31A friend.
01:20:32He thought we should have it back.
01:20:34What friend?
01:20:35Yep.
01:20:35He's waiting outside.
01:20:55And what are you planning to do with this?
01:21:02As a lawyer, I'm obliged to advise you that
01:21:05what you're doing could be construed
01:21:07as an obstruction of justice.
01:21:35Should have done this when you told me to.
01:21:59In an extraordinary development today,
01:22:18the Middlesex County Rape Crisis Center
01:22:20burned the files of over 3,000 current and former clients.
01:22:24Defense attorneys were outraged,
01:22:26calling the act of flagrant obstruction of justice.
01:22:29The director of the center said that until rape laws begin to focus
01:22:32on the perpetrators of the crime,
01:22:34they will keep no further record of consultations with clients.
01:22:37Barbara Mashai 측 Be已经
01:22:38so房長,
01:22:42she is going also at
01:22:45Angela's legal
01:22:50with Amazon division.
01:22:50Susan Colfax.
01:22:51Anna Marie Martinez.
01:22:53Roberta Hanson.
01:22:55Donah Jones.
01:22:56Jessica Harris.
01:22:57Terri Holman, Debbie Mills, Karen Green.
01:23:27Terri Holman, Debbie Mills, Karen Green.
01:23:57Terri Holman, Debbie Mills, Karen Green.
Be the first to comment