Kiss of the Spider Woman: Novel to Adaptations

Thắng Huỳnh Quang

2 ngày trước

The provided sources offer an extensive overview of Manuel Puig's 1976 novel, Kiss of the Spider Woman, and its subsequent adaptations, particularly focusing on the 2025 film musical adaptation. The original novel, centered on the evolving relationship between a homosexual window dresser named Molina and a Marxist political prisoner named Valentín in an Argentine prison, explores themes of political activism, human emotion, and gender fluidity. Several reviews for the Bill Condon-directed musical film praise the performances of Tonatiuh as Molina and Diego Luna as Valentín, noting that the adaptation successfully separates the prison drama from the musical fantasy sequences inspired by Molina’s movie recounts, which often feature Jennifer Lopez as the movie star Ingrid Luna/Spider Woman. The texts also mention the Tony-Award winning 1993 Broadway musical by Kander and Ebb and the critically acclaimed 1985 film adaptation starring William Hurt, contrasting Hurt’s portrayal with Tonatiuh’s performance in the newer version. Collectively, the sources examine the narrative’s continued relevance regarding LGBTQ+ identity, resistance against oppression, and the power of art as escapism and solace.

Danh mục

🗞

Tin tức

Phụ đề

Hiển thị phụ đề video đầy đủ

00:00All right, let's talk about this one story, an incredible story that just seems to reinvent

00:05itself over and over again. I mean, think about it. It starts as a novel, becomes an Oscar-winning

00:11drama, then a huge Broadway hit, and now a major movie musical. So what is the secret behind Kiss

00:18of the Spider-Woman? Why has this one single story managed to captivate people for almost

00:24half a century? Well, that's what we're going to unpack. And you can see that journey right here.

00:30It's pretty amazing. Kicking off in 1976 as the super experimental novel, then an Oscar-winning

00:37film, a Broadway smash, and now a whole new movie musical reimagining. It's like the story

00:44shapeshifts for every new generation, you know? So to really get why this story has such a grip on us,

00:51we've got to strip it all the way down. Forget the Oscars, forget the Tonys. At its heart,

00:56it's about two prisoners in one cell. And that setting? Wow. It's not just a room. We're talking

01:02a grim, claustrophobic cell during Argentina's dirty war. This was a really dark, oppressive time. So

01:07the prison itself, it's like a third character in the story, this constant force trying to crush

01:12these two men. And this is where the sparks really fly. You've got these two guys who are polar opposites.

01:20First, there's Melina, the escapist. He's a window dresser who's all about romance,

01:25glamour, Hollywood fantasies. Then you have Valentin, the realist, a hardcore Marxist

01:30revolutionary who thinks all that personal stuff is just a distraction from the real fight.

01:35I mean, you couldn't pick two more different people to lock in a room together.

01:40So the question is, how do you even survive that? How do you get through the day? Well,

01:44Melina, he's got a secret weapon. It's all about fantasy versus reality.

01:49To escape the absolute horror of their situation, we're talking torture, confinement,

01:54Melina starts telling stories. He recounts his favorite old movies, these 1940s melodramas,

02:00in incredible detail. He's basically painting a picture with his words right on the prison walls,

02:06and it becomes an escape for both of them. And what I love is this quote from Melina. He says,

02:11it's not Citizen Kane. Call it kitsch, call it camp. I don't care. I love it. He knows these movies

02:18aren't, you know, high art. They're a little over the top. But that's not the point. The point is the

02:23feeling they give him, the escape they offer. That's what makes them so valuable. And this is

02:28where the real magic happens. These stories, they become a bridge. Suddenly, this tiny, awful prison

02:34cell is a place where these two total opposites can actually connect. They start to find common ground,

02:39intimacy, humanity. It's amazing. Okay, so that's the core of the story. Now let's look at its

02:45evolving legacy. Because how this story has been told and retold through the years is just as

02:50fascinating. It all kicks off in 1976. And the original novel by Manuel Puig, it was seriously

02:58experimental. He wrote it in exile from the dictatorship in Argentina. The book uses all this

03:03unconventional formatting, like footnotes and tons of dialogue. And it really dives deep into the

03:08fluidity of gender and sexuality. It was a radical book for a radical time. Okay, fast forward to 1985.

03:16This is when it really exploded into the mainstream. Hector Babenko's film was a huge deal. It was the

03:22first independent film ever to get a Best Picture nomination at the Oscars. William Hurt won Best

03:28Actor for playing Melina. But it also kicked off a huge debate about a straight actor playing a queer

03:33role. A conversation that honestly we're still having today. All right, next up 1993. And this is

03:40where things get really interesting. They turned it into a Broadway musical. And the score was by

03:46Kander and Ebb. These are the legends who wrote Cabaret and Chicago. It won a ton of Tonys, including

03:53Best Musical. What made it so brilliant was how it put the grim reality of the prison cell right next to

04:00these huge, dazzling fantasy musical numbers. You felt that contrast between fantasy and reality

04:06in a whole new way. And that brings us right up to 2025. So there's a new movie musical in the works

04:14from director Bill Condon, and it feels like what one critic called a satisfying course correction.

04:19This time, Melina is played by Tonitua Gorthurbanis, a queer, non-binary actor, which is a huge step.

04:25And structurally, they're really separating the prison drama from the fantasy musical numbers,

04:29letting each part shine. So after all this time, all these different versions, why does it still

04:36resonate so much? Why does this story feel like it's for right now? I mean, a story that's almost

04:4350 years old feeling this urgent? There's got to be a reason. And I think it really comes down to a

04:48few core things. First, you've got this idea of art as resistance. Storytelling isn't just a hobby

04:54here. It's a weapon for survival against this oppressive government. Then there's the idea of finding

04:59humanity in the worst possible places. These two men from completely different worlds learn to

05:04actually care for each other. And finally, it completely redefines identity and love. It

05:09challenges all these rigid ideas about gender, sexuality, and even what it means to be a

05:13revolutionary. These are the things that keep it feeling so powerful. It's like what one critic said.

05:18The story feels like it's in direct conversation with the chaotic and dystopian reality of the now.

05:23It just seems to pop up right when we need to hear its message the most.

05:28And that really gets to the core of it, right? The story asks, what's the role of art and joy

05:33when everything feels like it's falling apart, when their very existence is threatened? That is the

05:38central question here. So in a world that always seems to be demanding that we choose a side,

05:44what can we really learn from a story where the ultimate revolution isn't found in a slogan,

05:49but in a simple act of compassion? That's something to think about.

Hãy là người đầu tiên nhận xét

Thêm nhận xét của bạn

Được khuyến cáo