Cosplay and Copyright: Why aren't cosplayers arrested?

The Best Anime Here

Why aren’t cosplayers arrested for copyright infringement? 🤔🎭 Cosplay — dressing up and performing as anime, manga, or video game characters — seems like it should violate copyright laws… but in practice, it usually doesn’t. In this video, we break down the legal reasons why cosplayers rarely face legal action, even when they replicate copyrighted designs, while AI-generated images are now facing bans and even arrests in Japan.  We’ll explore: ⚖️ How Japanese copyright law treats cosplay as a cultural phenomenon. 🇺🇸 The differences between U.S. and European copyright systems regarding fan art and performances. 💡 Why AI art is being punished more severely than cosplay — and what this means for creators. 🎎 Real-world examples of lawsuits, new regulations, and statements from Japanese authorities.  If you love anime, cosplay, or just want to understand the gray area between creativity and copyright, this video dives deep into the topic.  🔔 Subscribe for more anime analysis, legal curiosities, and cultural deep dives! 👍 Like, comment your opinion — should cosplay remain free from copyright laws?

Transcript

00:00Cosplay involves dressing up and portraying characters from anime, manga, video games,

00:05or movies. At first glance, copying the appearance of a copyrighted character might seem illegal.

00:10Technically, it reproduces a protected work. However, in practice, amateur cosplayers are

00:15rarely prosecuted, while the sale of AI-generated images has begun to be punished. In this video,

00:20we explore the legal reasons behind this difference. We will discuss the laws in Japan,

00:25where cosplay is deeply rooted, the rules in countries such as the United States and Europe,

00:30and recent cases of generative AI that have led to arrests. First of all, it is important to

00:35understand that copyright protects the specific expressions of a work, the script of a film,

00:40the original drawing of a character, the music, not abstract ideas. An anime character can be

00:45highly protected if it has a distinctive and recurring design. Legally, a character's costume

00:50is itself a derivative work. You reproduce the character's clothing, colors, and still image.

00:55In general terms, creating and distributing derivative works without the owner's permission

00:59may infringe copyright law. For example, printing and selling posters featuring anime characters

01:05without authorization constitutes an illegal business. However, amateur cosplay is different.

01:10It is a physical recreation, often done on a non-profit basis and in amateur contexts.

01:15In addition, rights holders sometimes consider cosplay to be free advertising for their brand,

01:20which influences how they react. Reproduction vs. Transformation

01:24When a cosplayer reproduces a character, it could be considered copying. But in many countries,

01:29there is the notion of transformative use, especially in the US, that can protect cosplay.

01:34In the US, for example, it is argued that cosplay is transformative because it does not seek to

01:39replace the original work but to pay homage to it. Non-commercial nature

01:43A key factor is whether or not cosplay is a commercial activity. In Japan, and also in practice in other

01:49jurisdictions, it is generally accepted that someone who dresses up as a hobby and does not receive

01:54payment is not a target for the authorities. If the cosplayer makes a living by selling photos,

01:59appearing at events, or promoting products, that changes things. History of Tolerance

02:03Japan has a long tradition of fan art, digenshi, cosplay, and fan fiction being tolerated as long as

02:09they do not harm the rights holder. Our anime companies often see cosplay as a form of free advertising.

02:15In fact, it has been pointed out that cosplay functions as free advertising that enhances

02:20the value of the original product, making it less attractive for creators to initiate lawsuits.

02:25In Japan, cosplay is an important cultural expression. It has become a multi-million

02:30dollar industry at both local and international conventions. This led the Japanese government to

02:35consider clarifying the copyright rules for cosplay. However, the official goal has not been to crack

02:40down on fans, but rather to regulate professionals and ensure that cosplay benefits everyone.

02:45Legal sources express it this way, Japan emphasized that the new measures would only apply in cases

02:50of profit, that is, to professional cosplayers who receive payment for their appearances.

02:55In summary, the position in Japan has been, if a cosplayer attends a convention as a hobby and

03:00without earning money, copyright law does not seek to punish that activity. There is consensus that

03:05in such cases, Japanese copyright laws are not being broken. If a cosplayer sells photos, merchandise,

03:11or commercial agreements using someone else's character, then there could be a possible violation.

03:16For example, attending paid events dressed as a character can be considered profit from someone

03:21else's work. The Japanese government has publicly clarified that it seeks to protect cosplay culture,

03:26not eliminate it. It has been said that cosplay is an important manifestation of Japanese culture

03:31and that there is no desire to affect this creative industry with excessive regulations.

03:35Therefore, changes are being studied to clarify permitted cases, facilitate licensing, and only

03:41penalize commercial use without permission. In other words, only professional cosplayers could be

03:46affected, and even then, it is insisted that the laws will not be as restrictive as feared.

03:51In practice, Japanese cosplayers who are not seeking profit continue to enjoy great freedom.

03:56The situation varies in other countries, but they share some commonalities. United States,

04:01there, the fair use system can protect cosplayers. Although there is no guarantee, many judges would

04:06consider cosplay to be transformative and not commercially competitive with the original work.

04:11In addition, rights holders often view cosplay as free publicity and do not usually sue for it.

04:16It has been documented that the lack of copyright litigation against cosplayers is due to several

04:21factors. Creators appreciate the free promotion, do not want to upset their fans,

04:25and suing would be difficult and counterproductive. Even Disney is cited as an example,

04:30which could take action against a costume seller, but usually avoid suing a famous

04:34cosplayer directly so as not to generate a bad image. In general, except for clear-cut cases,

04:40e.g., a cosplayer selling exact replicas of registered costumes, as demonstrated by the

04:45example of Barney costumes in the US, cosplay has been met with greater tolerance.

04:50Europe, European law is stricter, there is no broad fair use, but there are almost no known cases of

04:55lawsuits over cosplay. In many countries, there is an exception for private use or small reproductions,

05:01but what is really decisive is the cultural attitude. As in Japan, cosplay is considered

05:06part of pop culture and is not usually prosecuted except in cases of clear abuse. In short, cosplayers

05:12in the West benefit from similar factors, transformative use, lack of serious commercial harm,

05:17and appreciation from the creators. Courts find it difficult to convict an amateur for dressing up,

05:22while creators focus their energy on more harmful infringements. No profit motive,

05:26laws focus on punishing commercial use only. Japanese authorities insist that only cosplay

05:32for profit will be punished. Free publicity, cosplay raises the visibility of a franchise.

05:37That is why it is argued that cosplay is free publicity that enhances the value of the original

05:42product, reducing the willingness to sue. Transformative nature, wearing a costume and

05:46acting like a character is seen as a use different from the original medium. Many legal experts believe

05:51that this transformation strengthens the defense of fair use in the US. Practical difficulty,

05:56proving infringement in cosplay is complex. The copied object is a character, not a specific text or

06:02image, and cosplay is often episodic and personal. Courts are wary of setting broad precedents.

06:08Fan culture and cool Japan, the Japanese industry itself promotes cosplay, it even has cosplay ambassadors.

06:14There is a fear that regulating it harshly would spoil global otaku culture,

06:18so laws are applied with caution. These factors explain the general impunity of amateur cosplayers.

06:24Those who do not sell anything usually remain off the legal radar. In contrast,

06:28cases involving AI art have been met with police action. In January 2025, two men in Japan were

06:34arrested for violating copyright law by creating and selling explicit AI-generated posters of popular anime

06:41characters. The photograph shows the AI-generated posters that Japanese police seized in the recent

06:46operation. These images show anime girls, such as Evangelion, and sexual poses created by AI without

06:53authorization. The suspects used AI prompts on copyrighted characters, printed the illustrations,

06:58and sold them at online options. According to the police, one made about 10 million yen

07:03and the other 5.7 million yen selling these posters. Both confessed to the offense after being caught.

07:08This case clearly meets the elements of an infringement. It involved generating derivative

07:13art from protected characters and marketing it without permission. The international press reported

07:18that the defendants have been charged with violating Japan's copyright law for illegally creating and

07:22selling obscene AI-generated posters of popular anime characters. In addition to being illegal, the

07:28content was pornographic, which aggravated the response. In April 2025, another arrest of four people for

07:35selling AI-generated erotic images on suspicion of illegal pornography was even reported. In short,

07:41the sale of derivative digital works is considered piracy. Japanese law protects original art, and

07:46although AI only generates something new, it does so based on millions of pieces of copyrighted data.

07:52When someone prints and sells these images, they are commercially exploiting unlicensed third-party

07:57works. That is why the authorities acted quickly against AI-generators. In light of the above,

08:02we see clear contrasts. Means of exploitation, the cosplayer sells their image or appearances,

08:08if they do so for profit, but does not distribute the original work. In contrast, the AI-generator

08:13sells printed images of the characters. Selling a poster is a direct form of distribution of

08:18copyrighted material, while posing in costume usually generates private or promotional photos.

08:23Manual versus automatic transformation. Cosplay involves craftsmanship, costume-making,

08:28acting, so it can be granted more leeway as personal creative use. AI, on the other hand,

08:34automatically generates content from massive amounts of data, the result can be considered less new,

08:39closer to copying elements of the original work in the final product. Scale and profit. In the case

08:43of AI, there was a clearly defined business, thousands of dollars for posters on the internet.

08:48Many amateur cosplayers do not earn direct income from their cosplay. The laws target the commercial

08:53exploitation of someone else's intellectual property, which is why the profit component was decisive in

08:59the AI arrests. Sensitive content. Some AI cases involve pornography or defamation, such as desecrated

09:06waifus. Although copyright infringement was the charge, the sexual nature of the images intensified

09:11the police and public response. Cosplay does not generally involve illegal content in this sense,

09:16so there are no additional grounds for legal action. In short, amateur cosplayers operate in a

09:21grey area tolerated by the law, while AI generators were in clearly illegal territory,

09:27using protective works to create and sell explicit material. Although in theory any unauthorized

09:32reproduction of a character violates copyright, in practice there are nuances. In Japan and other

09:37jurisdictions, cultural promotion is prioritized and illegal profit is primarily prosecuted. Amateur

09:43cosplayers are seen as fans who enrich the brand, not as pirates to be prosecuted. That is why today

09:48there are no mass complaints against ordinary cosplayers, nor are there laws that expressly criminalize

09:54them. In contrast, recent cases show that the red line is business. Generating explicit art with AI

09:59and selling it without permission crosses legal boundaries. The arrests in January and April 2025

10:05reflect that the authorities are indeed going after those who profit from derivative works,

10:09especially in an automated manner. In conclusion, the current legal and social response favors fan

10:15cosplay, as long as it remains a cultural and non-commercial activity. Even so, it is advisable to

10:21practice cosplay with respect. Many professional cosplayers already ask creators for permission or

10:26invent their own designs to avoid conflicts. Finally, it is important to note that the situation may

10:31evolve. Both Japan and other countries will study laws on AI and cosplay. But today, cosplay does not

10:37lead to jail time, while the illegal sale of AIR does. I would like to leave the following message. As

10:42mentioned, one of the reasons why the men were arrested is for generating explicit content of anime

10:47characters such as those from Evangelion, but there are also many cosplayers who create adult content

10:53dressed up and playing anime characters, so I don't think the laws are being fair to artificial

10:57intelligence. Remember that to learn to draw, you first have to learn to copy, and this is what

11:02artificial intelligence does. However, it is true that if artificial intelligence is allowed to do too

11:08many things, it could end up causing bigger problems. Let me know what you think about this topic in the comments.

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended