This is the case of Lee Rodarte, who infamously was smarter than the detectives but still fell short.

#truecrime #psychology
Transcript
00:00Where is she? I don't know where she is. Where is Savannah? No, no, no. Where did you go with her?
00:05I know you're not that cruel inside. I'm begging you, Lee. Just tell us. I don't know where she is.
00:11This is Lee Rodarte, a man taken into custody for being suspected of kidnapping and killing his
00:17co-worker, Savannah Gold. With no ideas of where Savannah could be, the cops knew getting this
00:22interrogation wrong could mean they might never catch the killer. What's even worse is that Lee
00:28had a foolproof story that was going to make sure Savannah was never to be found. Lee, however,
00:35is under the impression that he is smarter than the detectives. Little did he know this would be a
00:41massive mistake for him. On the 2nd of August, 2017, Savannah's family received text messages stating
00:48she was running away and quitting her job. The messages were riddled with errors, causing her
00:53family to panic and report her as missing immediately. Throughout the investigation,
00:57the police were grasping at straws until they were suddenly sent the CCTV footage from the
01:04Bonefish Grill where Savannah worked. The video shows her getting into a silver car in the parking
01:09lot before it began to shake violently, with the door being thrust open and pulled shut three times.
01:15The car then drove out of the parking lot and Savannah was never seen again. After a series of
01:21interviews, they discovered the car was identical to Lee Rodarte's, a manager at the grill and boyfriend
01:27to Savannah for around two months. Lee was immediately arrested on suspicion of murder and brought into
01:33the interrogation room. However, he was told by police it was for an unimportant traffic warrant.
01:38And that's when the following happened.
01:41I'll stay right out here. You can go have a seat for me real quick. I'll be right back, okay?
01:46Yes, sir. Being told the detective will be right back obviously implies to Lee that he won't have
01:52to wait long to be seen. But it'd actually be 90 minutes before anyone enters the room again.
01:57Only a few days ago, Lee was interviewed about the disappearance of a girl he kidnapped and now
02:02he's been handcuffed and taken into a police interrogation room. Lee will be feeling incredibly
02:08anxious now. But remember, he's confident that there's no way the cops have enough evidence to
02:13take him down. But unfortunately for him, the facade the detectives put up is all about to be ripped
02:19away.
02:20Hey, man. How you doing?
02:21Good, good. You remember me from the other day? Detective Reeves?
02:23Okay. Um, this is my partner, Detective Salis.
02:27The detective that enters isn't the same one that brought him in. It's the one who interviewed him
02:31about Savannah three days prior. Any comfort he found in thinking this was all unrelated has now
02:36been completely taken away and replaced with pure panic. But Lee's plan remains the same. So he tries
02:42to keep himself composed as he prepares for the onslaught of questions he's about to be hit with.
02:48So, um, Savannah, you said that you knew her and you guys had, um, you knew her from work. I mean,
02:53just kind of fill me in with that. How long have you known her?
02:56Um, like I said, I've known her obviously since she worked, since she started working there.
03:01Um, I would say probably about eight months ago, we started hanging out outside of work.
03:06And at the time I had a girlfriend, but I kind of, you know, we kind of connected me and Savannah.
03:12So we hung out a little bit here and there, got pretty close. Uh, we come from, I guess,
03:18somewhat similar backgrounds, I guess you should say.
03:21The question Lee was given was how long have you known Savannah? A question that surely merits a
03:26fairly simple answer. When hit with a question like this, people who have nothing to hide,
03:31keep their responses short, taking the questions at face value. But people who feel pressured will
03:36usually extend their answers to questions in an effort to seem as though they know what they're
03:40talking about. Something Lee will fall victim to.
03:44Uh, so we kind of connected and hung out for a little while. Uh, I'd probably say a period of
03:50two, three months. Okay. Um, and then she started using, uh, drugs a lot. I did them with her a couple
04:00of times and then she started to get heavy into them. Oh, gotcha. Okay. Um, so I kind of just, uh,
04:08tried to take a step back and, you know, put things off. And then probably a month or so ago,
04:17I saw Savannah at work and she looked healthy again. You know, she gained a little bit of weight.
04:22Uh, we kind of were talking, you know, here and there, we hung out a couple of times. Um,
04:27she came over to the house and, you know, we just kicked back, drank a couple of beers,
04:31watched movies, stuff like that.
04:32In total, Lee spoke for over five minutes in response to a single simple question,
04:38going so far as to detail specific encounters between the pair. Now that the detectives have
04:43even more reason to suspect that he may be hiding something, they decide to call him out on something
04:48small to gauge his reaction. In the first interview, Lee had told investigators he hadn't seen Savannah
04:53in a while. But if the CCTV footage is to be believed, this is a bold faced lie.
04:59And then as we hung out, you know, after a couple of times, she brought drugs over. I told her,
05:04I was like, you know, you're doing really good. You can't, you know, you shouldn't be doing it
05:09again. I think we moved too fast. Split mutual ways. Right. Yeah. And that was the last time that we
05:15text. Okay. When was that? Uh, it was probably a couple, two, three weeks ago. Okay. Sometime in July.
05:22Right. Right. Yeah. And I think that's one of the things you said was that was the last time that you
05:26had contact with her as far as, I don't want to put words in your mouth. So, I mean, you, you correct
05:31me at any time. That was the last time that I texted her. Yeah. Text or a phone call or messenger or
05:37anything like that. Yeah. Two to three weeks ago. Yeah. Okay. And, um, and then the last time,
05:42when was the last time you saw her? This is what I was, I didn't tell you the truth when we talked up on
05:50fish. Okay. Last time I saw her was Wednesday afternoon. Okay. I heard that she has been
05:58basically telling a lot of people at work that we hooked up a bunch, like a couple of days before
06:05that. So I met her in the parking lot, uh, at Bonefish. When was this? Wednesday afternoon. Okay.
06:14Well, then you know what time or about? Um, it was about 5 30. Okay. Without realizing it,
06:20Lee has already provided us with enough evidence to assume he's guilty. We know he knew Savannah.
06:26He had the same vehicle seen in the footage and he was present at the scene of the crime when it happened.
06:31Remember, Lee has no idea the cops have footage of the event. If he knew about it, he would have tried
06:37to provide an alibi that put him somewhere completely different. Unfortunately though,
06:42this isn't quite enough evidence for the cops to get a guaranteed conviction. Instead, they need to push
06:48further to try and extract a full confession, something that will not come easy at all. I parked,
06:54uh, and I said, Hey, uh, can I talk to you for a second? And she said, Yeah, what's up?
07:00And I was like, I heard you've been saying some things about me and you continuing to hang out and
07:08you know, that we're boyfriend and girlfriend. And she asked me, she said, Can I come sit in the car?
07:16Because I just did some heroin and I'm a little paranoid. It was never confirmed that Savannah did
07:22do heroin. Nobody in her life mentioned seeing or suspecting she used it. And even if she did,
07:28she was headed to a shift at her job as this conversation was taking place. If she was able
07:33to do that without getting paranoid, it seems strange. She couldn't simply have a chat in the
07:37parking lot. So she came and sat in the car and I explained to her the situation. I told her that
07:42servers, uh, at Bonefish were coming to me and telling me that you're telling people when you're
07:49out that we're boyfriend and girlfriend. And I said, I need you to stop because for one,
07:54it's jeopardizing my job. We agreed to, you know, split, stop talking mutually and just move on. Um,
08:01but it was nothing more than that. And she said, I'm going to do what I want. I didn't tell anybody
08:06anything. At that point, I got out and I punched her the hole on the tire. And I said,
08:13no, stop. And I said, don't do it again. Or next time it's going to be worse. It's going to be your
08:18windows. At that point, she had her phone in her hand. She got out of the car and walked towards
08:25the main entrance from San Jose. Obviously this entire explanation was crafted to try
08:30and create an alibi as close as possible to what actually happened. But the few small inaccuracies
08:36are actually glaring windows directly into the truth. We know that Savannah never left the vehicle
08:41in the parking lot and that she drove away with him just minutes after getting in. Lee is unwittingly
08:47constructing a mountain of evidence against him in the form of lies that he thinks he's getting away
08:53with. And he's not finished yet. And it looked like she was either texting or calling somebody.
08:59Okay. Um, because as she started walking towards the, there's an entrance to the plaza. She was
09:07walking maybe towards this way. And I would say an older model Ford pickup, green, drove past me and
09:19around and she got in. Okay. How long do you think it was between the time that she got out and started
09:27using her phone until that green truck pulled up? Um, maybe five minutes. Okay. So, wow. So if she
09:33called somebody, they got there in five minutes to pick her up? Well, I mean, like I said, she, she,
09:38it looked like she was going to call somebody and that's when the green truck came around and she got
09:44in. So she gets in the truck. What, what happened at that point? Um, they drove back around, kind of
09:49looped around a little bit. Which way they drive? So I guess they exit that way. And at that point, I
09:58left. Lee doubles down on the lie again, thinking that this puts him completely in the clear as he
10:04wouldn't have been the last person to see Savannah, but his decisions continue to work against him.
10:09Had he decided to stick closer to the truth, he might've been able to argue that he took Savannah
10:14somewhere else and then parted ways with her. But without the knowledge of what police have against
10:19him, Lee is left simply guessing and forced to make up stories on the fly. This is why it's so important
10:25to call a lawyer innocent or not. In an interrogation, detectives are allowed to both lie and withhold
10:32evidence from you, putting you in a very difficult situation where you're at the mercy of their tactics
10:37and games. However, the second you bring an attorney into the mix, things get exponentially easier as
10:44police are forced to turn over all of the evidence in their possession so they can put together a fair
10:48and sound defense for you. Calling a lawyer isn't just having a wingman at the interrogation room.
10:54It's an unlocked door that bypasses almost all of the police's tricks. It goes from them
11:00interrogating you to a legal battle. But needless to say, Lee hasn't called the lawyer and has been
11:07left at a disadvantage from the beginning. If Lee was as smart as he thinks he is, he wouldn't have
11:12waived this right and likely would be in a much better position. What happened to your neck?
11:18That was self-inflicted, actually. Why? I just have been having kind of a hard time.
11:26To your neck? I couldn't. Yeah, I did. And... What did you use? A knife. When did you do that?
11:34Um... Sometime in July. You did that in July and it's still bloody? Yeah. Well, it's... I kind of
11:47peeled the scab here and there at work, hitting it on stuff like that. I peeled it last night working.
11:53And it was coming off a little bit today, so I peeled that a little bit. All right, let me see.
11:58But this and this was the same night. This one was just a lot worse than this one was.
12:03Okay. And that was in July?
12:08Yeah. Okay. Like a few weeks back? Yeah. Okay. It doesn't take a genius to realize how brazen of
12:14a lie this is. Aside from his incredibly unconvincing delivery of his excuses, Lee has no history with
12:21self-harm and was reported to have been in good spirits in the weeks leading up to this event.
12:26Furthermore, Lee becomes visibly anxious here. Most people have a tell that shows when they're lying
12:32or feeling uncomfortable. For many, this is crossing their arms or slouching in their chair.
12:37But Lee keeps his posture and position fairly consistent throughout the interview. Instead,
12:42Lee is prone to subconscious jittery movements in his limbs. Earlier in the interview, while being
12:47caught in his first lie, he bounced his leg repeatedly the entire time. While here,
12:52he moves his hand and fingers unnaturally every time he tells a lie. In fact, it's almost comical how
12:58perfectly it lines up with the false statements. It's also interesting to note that the detectives
13:15almost certainly noticed these marks just seconds into the interview. The decision to mention it now
13:20was a conscious one done to try and build pressure. Lee would likely have anxiety regarding his last
13:26big lie about Savannah exiting his vehicle. Catching him so suddenly in a second lie right after will
13:32likely amplify these feelings and cause him to feel even more paranoia as the detectives continue.
13:38This is also likely why they immediately flip back to talking about the truck right after.
13:42Lee could you see who the person in the truck was? Um, the truck had fairly tinted windows. I saw
13:48um, a baseball cap. Yeah. You see a guy, girl, light black. I couldn't really tell if it was a guy or a girl.
13:58I just remember seeing the truck drive and her get in. Yeah. Um, and all the time sitting in front and
14:04truck drives right past me. Yeah. And I saw a baseball cap through the passenger window. Okay. Um, but...
14:11So it seemed like she knew the person? I mean, she got right in. Lee, why didn't you mention this before
14:17since we've been looking for this girl? I mean, don't you think that information... I mean, it definitely,
14:20it definitely does. Um, and I regret obviously not seeing anything before. Um, so I, when I come up
14:28and talk to you yesterday, I'm not threatening. I'm just, I'm talking to everybody out there. What?
14:34Well, I just, you know, I freaked out to be honest with you. I mean, this girl was missing?
14:39Yes. Okay. But you know, she's been missing. I mean, I just, I mean, obviously, you know,
14:43I was the last one to see her. So I was a little bit scared at that. How do you know you're, you,
14:49you just said you weren't the last one to see her. You just said somebody in a truck. Well,
14:53I mean, the last one to see her at Bonefish. Okay. The last one she's heard from. Right. I had
14:57contact with that anybody knows though. Sure. The detective knows he's starting to catch Lee on
15:02the back foot. So decides to keep the pressure up. So where's Savannah right now? I don't know.
15:09Where would I find her? I don't know. That's my, my prime objective is to find her. Definitely. And
15:15here's a couple reasons I need to find her. One is, um, I'm hoping that, that she's still alive. Um,
15:21and that's really, I really do. I'm holding out for that. Um, and if she's not alive, then I think she,
15:28and her family are, are, are due that knowledge. I think they need some closure. So where is she?
15:35I don't know where she is. Where is Savannah? I don't know. I need to know where Savannah is.
15:39I don't know where she is. You don't know because you had something done with her and you weren't
15:45involved in that part. I don't know. Tell me something. What can I work with? I told you the
15:50last time I saw her. That's not true because we have proof. We have, we have proof. And that's why
15:55we're sitting here, Lee. At this point, we need this for her. I mean, I look at that little girl
16:00and I think of my little girl, my little girl, who's her age. That's who I think about. That
16:06was my little girl. I couldn't imagine. I don't care what she said about you or whatever, but
16:12my little girl is that age. Maybe. And you're not telling the truth. Maybe something gets out of
16:17hand in the car. I didn't do anything. Okay. You didn't do anything, but she was in your car. She
16:21never got out of your car. She never got out of your car. Lee. This is where the true genius of
16:28these detectives start to shine. The initially quiet female detective suddenly starts to speak
16:34up. The male detective had a very deadpan professional demeanor throughout the interrogation.
16:40So having that suddenly contrasted by a vulnerable, emotional looking person being thrust in front of
16:46him will likely come as even more of a shock to him, especially as she starts to become more emotive
16:52and even starts to beg him. She never gets out of that car and you drive off. She never gets out
16:58of that car. There is no green truck and that's not right to her. We're fact finders, Lee. I don't
17:03have anything personal against you. No, no, not at all. I mean, it's, it's, it's over.
17:08We're just fact finders. We're just doing our job.
17:13No, no, no. Where did you go with her? Where did you go with her, Lee? Be human. You're a human. You're a
17:19man. Where did you go with her? I know you're not that cruel inside. Maybe you, maybe you don't know
17:25where she is now. Where did you go with her? Please. I'm begging you, Lee. I know you're not
17:30an evil person. I don't see that in you. I don't see that in your history. I don't hear those things
17:37about you at work. Is she still at your house? No. Okay. Is she still in your car? No. Okay.
17:45Well, where is she? What was going on in the backseat? For the doors to be kicked open.
17:52She kicked open that door three times, Lee. She kicked it. We saw it. And you know, and you know,
17:58I'm not making it up because I wouldn't know this because I wasn't there unless we had video of it.
18:03Correct? Yes. Correct. I'm not trying to trick you. I'm just a fact finder. I mean, she was upset.
18:10She tried to slap me. I slapped her. She went to get out. I grabbed her around her waist and said,
18:20where are you going? Why are you hitting me? She calmed down and was left.
18:27Why would she be with you after that? I mean, we've gotten arguments plenty of times where she says
18:33she doesn't care what happens or anything like that. All right. Sometimes people do wrong things,
18:40right? Sometimes people make mistakes. It's what you do afterwards. I've got a family that needs
18:46closure. They are now coming to the reality that she's no longer with us. Do you want people to remember
18:52you as a guy who said, okay, look, I'm going to do the right thing? Or do you want your family and
18:58everybody else to think that you're some evil, heartless person who won't tell us where she is?
19:03I don't think you're that kind of guy. I don't think you're evil. Just tell us where she is.
19:07Closure for her family.
19:09Closure for her family.
19:13She was hitting me. She wouldn't stop and I'd squeeze back. I just, I squeezed her. Stop.
19:22You squeezed her around her neck or around her neck?
19:25She just wanted to let go. I didn't let go.
19:28Closure for her family. Where is she now?
19:30Closure for her family.
19:31Please tell us where she is.
19:33All I want to do is leave me alone. It's a pond on the west side of the Club du Clay.
19:41Club du Clay?
19:42Yeah.
19:43Okay.
19:43And Longchamp.
19:44Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay.
19:46Just a few days later, a dive team recovered the remains of Savannah Gold, burned and almost
19:52unrecognizable. So much so that her cause of death couldn't even be determined.
19:58Lee Rodarte pleaded guilty to the second degree murder of Savannah and in March of 2021,
20:04was sentenced to 40 years behind bars.