- 1 year ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00Previously, I had published this video in which we revisited Shankarnath's trending value investing
00:04strategy. If you don't know who Shankarnath is, please check out his YouTube channel. He's one
00:08of my favorite financial educators. And in today's video, we are going to be looking at another gem
00:12of his work. This is the GARP or the growth at reasonable price investing strategy. In this video,
00:16I'll walk you through what GARP investing actually is. And number two, Shankar had backlisted four
00:21popular GARP investing formulations out there. And we will review the final results of his
00:26backlisting and what he found out. We will then finally come to Shankar's own proposal for
00:29this strategy. And we will compare how this one did in comparison to the four other popular
00:34versions. I will introduce you to a free Python utility that I built that automates Shankar's
00:39entire stock selection process based on his optimized GARP strategy. This way, you don't
00:43have to spend hours screening for stocks. So this utility with just a click of a button
00:45will extract all the list of eligible stocks for you. Also, I will show you live P&L position
00:50of a small portfolio that I built using this strategy. And by the end of this video, you
00:54will find out whether it ended up profitable for me or I lost my shirt on that one. So if
00:59you are someone who's tired of guessworks and want a smarter, proven and a scalable way to
01:03invest, stick around. This might just change the way you look at stock picking forever.
01:07The content trade in this video is based on my personal experience and is meant purely for
01:10education and information purposes. It is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice and
01:13should not be considered a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any financial instruments. Please
01:16remember that investing and trading involve significant risk of loss and past performance is
01:20not indicative of future results. Always do your own research and consult with a qualified
01:22financial tax and legal professional before making any financial decision.
01:24Welcome back. If you haven't seen my previous video on the trending value investing strategy,
01:28please do take a look. I provided the link of that video in the description.
01:33I would like to begin by thanking Shankarnath for his fantastic work. And if I only managed to do
01:38a half-decent job of how he explained this in his video, I think my work here is going to be a success.
01:43So let's begin. Let's first try and understand what GARP really is. Most investors have a split
01:47between two schools of thought, right? The first one is the value investing, where you buy what's cheap.
01:51And then the second one is called the growth investing, where you chase what's fast growing.
01:55Right? But what if there was a middle path, a way to harness best of the both worlds,
01:59to buy companies that are not just growing fast, but are also reasonably priced.
02:02That's exactly what GARP or the growth at reasonable price investing is all about.
02:06Popularized by the legendary Peter Lynch, I think GARP is a philosophy that doesn't just settle for
02:11either cheap or fast growing stocks alone. It looks a bit deeper, right? It asks that fundamental
02:15question, is this company's future growth already overpriced by the market? Or is this company a hidden gem?
02:20Right? So Shankar's video explained how most investors use price to earnings ratio incorrectly
02:25to see if a stock is overvalued or undervalued. You might have heard that when the P-E ratio of a
02:30stock is 50, oh, that's overvalued, stay away from it, right? Shankar clearly explains that the ratio
02:34that gives the more accurate reflection of its value, it does not be the P-E ratio,
02:37but the P-E ratio, which is the price to earnings to growth ratio. And he feels this is the correct
02:42measure, right? This idea was originally put forth by Peter Lynch. And this ratio is also calculated,
02:47you know, quite evidently, you divide price by the earnings to growth value and you get the P-E ratio.
02:52The traditional wisdom of how the P-E ratio is used is if the P-E ratio is less than one,
02:56then the stock is considered to be undervalued. If it is more than one, then the value of the,
02:59you know, the stock is overvalued. And if the P-E ratio remains at one, then the stock is considered
03:04to be a fair value. But Shankar in his video goes on to explain how even this traditional approach is
03:09wrong since the market structures have completely changed since the time this ratio was introduced.
03:14So that's why you will see, which comes later, you will see that he actually considers P-E ratio
03:17between zero and two is a better way of evaluating the stock. But more on that later. Shankar has done
03:23a fantastic job of analyzing four versions of this investing style and has already performed a
03:27backtest on each one of them. And these are the findings of those four items. The first one is the
03:32traditional Peter Lynch version that emphasizes comparing the historic P with the projected growth
03:35of the company. The exact criteria of the stock selection is already provided here. When he
03:39backtested it, he got a standing 113% return per annum for that particular year. The second one
03:44is a model proposed by Ishmohit, another favorite YouTuber of mine. I'm sure pretty much everyone
03:48of you are aware of him. Many of them also know him by his channel SOIC. He had come up with a slightly
03:54modified version with emphasis on the actual revenue numbers rather than just P-E. So his composition
03:58takes into account the sales growth and along with it, the profit growth of the company. When this was
04:03backtested, the results gave him 110% return for the same testing period. The third model was the one
04:09that Economic Times had published and this one explicitly uses the PEG ratio. As part of this
04:13backtest, Shankar got too many stocks, almost close to about 131 to be precise, and then he couldn't test
04:20all of it. But when he randomly tested about 10 of those, the returns were around 51%, which is way
04:25below than the previous two versions. And the last one, which is the S&P 500 GARP index approach,
04:31this is a very famous index. Although he could not backtest this specific item due to the lack
04:36of data, he had included that in the mix to get an overall inspiration for his own model LUTs that he
04:41basically came up with. Now, finally, we are on to Shankar's own method and here's his selection criteria.
04:46So Shankar has managed to pick the best learnings from all four models and has included the key
04:50drivers like the PEG ratio, the revenue growth, the profit projection, and also historical EPS growth.
04:55Of course, to this, I've added the current price less than 10,000. This is just a thing that I added
05:00because I was trying to build a model based on this and I wanted to keep my allocation per stock
05:04under 10K. So you can choose to ignore that if you want. So now the question is, how did Shankar's
05:09model perform in the backtest? I'm sure you're keen to know. Well, this version managed to deliver
05:14a whopping 115% for the same testing period and same test conditions and managed to beat all other
05:19versions that we discussed so far. Now that we know we have a winning formula from Shankar, I think the
05:23next question is, I mean, how do we screen for these stocks and then get this list? So Shankar's basically
05:30explained it using a manual screening method using the screener.in and I promised you that I'll
05:34provide you an automated way of doing this. So here's the Python implementation of the screener.
05:39All of the details that I just covered is already available in this blog article along with the
05:42entire Python implementation of that screener. All you need to do is just run the screen and then this
05:46basically will extract data from screener.in for the specific criteria that we already discussed
05:51and then we'll provide you a list of stocks that are eligible for investment. So I have a general appeal to make.
05:57Close to 80% of the people who watch my videos don't seem to be subscribing. As you're aware,
06:01this community is just one person initiative dedicated to help people on their fire and
06:04well-building journey. Running and maintaining this community takes time, effort and resources
06:07from my side. One way you could support this community is by subscribing, liking and also
06:11sharing this content with your friends. This will motivate me to do more such videos and keep
06:14this community alive. Thank you. So what I've done is, apart from just running the street scan for the
06:19criteria that he gave, I've also included three critical information, which is the returns that these
06:24particular stocks have given in the last three months, six months and 12 months. This is for
06:29people who want to look at short-term, how these stocks have done. So some people are, they look at
06:34short-term returns. So for them, you could consider three months and then sort the list based on the
06:39returns of three months and then pick the top 25 or 10 or how much ever you want, which has given you
06:43the maximum returns rate. For people who are a bit medium-term like me, I prefer the last six months' returns.
06:49So this is the list that I've taken. So I typically sorted by descending the final Excel sheet that gets
06:54downloaded. I sorted by descending and then take the top 25 for my investment. People for a little
06:59bit more longer-term view of things, they can also consider the 12 months return. So this information is
07:03also available in the final carp.excel sheet that gets downloaded. So depending upon what type of an
07:08investor you are and your risk appetite, you can consider one of these three columns sorted accordingly and
07:13then pick up the top 10 or 25 stocks and then use it for your use. Let me also quickly show you
07:19how the Python implementation works in reality. So this is the Python program. You will definitely
07:23have to install these three. More specifically, the Beautiful Soup, you need to have the latest
07:28version installed. Otherwise, the scraping doesn't work on Screener.nl. You'll probably get some sort
07:32of an error. So please, if you are getting any errors, please ensure that the first thing that you've
07:37installed the right versions on it. And then when you run it, you get the list of the stocks that are
07:42eligible in a list like this, but you also get an Excel sheet with all the details downloaded. Let me just
07:47quickly walk you through that. Another change you will have to do, sorry, I forgot to mention,
07:52is that I'm basically storing this file in the D colon. Depending upon your machine, you'll probably
07:56have to change this location where you finally want this file stored. That's one change that
08:00you will have to take care of. So this is the final Excel sheet that will get downloaded. You'll
08:03have all the stock names, the current market price. Like I mentioned, you'll have these three
08:06information, the three months, six months and one year return. So depending upon which one you want,
08:10you could do it. This sheet is already sorted based on the six months return. So I mean, typically, you would
08:16consider the first 10 or 20 or 25 stocks as the final list of stocks that you want to select.
08:22At the beginning of the video, I promise that I'll show you my portfolio. So I invested a small amount
08:26and created a model portfolio based on this strategy. And here's where it stands. I couldn't have chosen a
08:31worse time for starting this investing. I did this during the first week of October, and I'm sure you
08:35know what happened thereafter. Nifty basically took a nose dive from mid of October, and we've been in a bear
08:41market ever since. So as it stands, I'm about 16% underwater on this one. However, I love the
08:48strategy and feel that the logic overall is very solid. So I'm confident and will continue to stay
08:53invested in this. And then I expect the situation to probably turn around quickly as the market
08:58requires, which is already looking like it's already happening. I'm sorry, but I can't take specific stock
09:04names here because that will be construed as investment advice. So this is definitely not investment advice.
09:09So we should not blindly invest. And that definitely is not the intention of this video.
09:14As far as I'm concerned, I'm determined to hold my position on this. I will provide you an update
09:18on the progress at regular intervals so that you know how this is progressing. So let me know what
09:23you think of the strategy and what additional optimizations probably you would make on this one.
09:26I would love to hear that from you. So until we meet again on another video, take care and happy
09:32investing. Thank you. If you genuinely found this video useful, please consider subscribing and liking the
09:35video. And I will see you soon in another video. And until then, take care and happy trading.