Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 6 weeks ago
"An in-depth investigation into the crash that left two dead and a community searching for the truth. Was it murder or misfortune? Watch The Dark Stories full episode."

true crime, true crime documentary, dark stories, murder mystery, courtroom drama, high speed crash, mackenzie shirilla case, intentional car crash, forensic evidence, crime scene analysis, murder trial, crime investigation, ohio murder case, deep dive true crime, crime podcast, crime series, strongsville ohio crash, young love tragedy, criminal justice, life sentence case, murder verdict, unsolved questions, accident or murder, true crime 2025, crime breakdown, court evidence analysis

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00I'm a Kenzie step out for me
00:30I'm Detective Hazu I'm the one who's been investigating the crash
00:34you're under arrest for aggravated murder times two okay nobody's gonna
00:38ask you any questions nobody's gonna bother you
00:41can I have your key please could you please be careful taking this one off so
00:44it doesn't break the bracelet you got it you got it
00:48no thank you you got it
00:55yeah just keep your hands right here
01:00I'm not done it I'm not gonna tighten these okay
01:15I don't want to hurt you
01:20you good are they good
01:39thank you all right this cruiser right here
01:43actually he took her out of the car and we did not okay do you have anything
01:55you're gonna watch your head going in
02:09I'm not going to hurt you
02:25walk out
02:26okay
02:36recording mounted wi-fi connected recording mounted wi-fi connected
02:48sorry
03:02help me get my foot out sorry
03:04it's just like
03:12this way
03:16just stand right by that black mat
03:24straight forward
03:26over there?
03:28yep until that door
03:32just stuck on that yellow line
03:34and just face the wall
03:36is that coming back?
03:48is that coming back?
03:50i think so yeah
03:52ok
03:54this is the county juvenile fish
03:56yeah
03:58um
04:00i don't know why they have like
04:02ten of these i think they're all the same
04:04i don't know
04:06it's just hers hers hers hers hers
04:08i don't know
04:10i'll he's coming back
04:12i think
04:14eleven
04:20eleven are you going to come back to the booking room?
04:24affirm
04:26i'm on the phone with her attorney
04:28samar
04:30copy
04:32what's your first name?
04:34i'm talking
04:38i'm talking
04:39yeah i'm talking
04:40mckenzie
04:42if you can cut off
04:43i need like all the jewelry and everything to come off
04:44ok
04:45i can't wear any of it
04:46no i need you to take it off while you're in jail right now
04:48i can't wear any of it
04:50no i need you to take it off while you're in jail right now
04:52i can't wear any of it
04:54unfortunately everything's going to have to come off of right now once we know
04:58when the detective comes back and we know for sure what's going on
05:00everything's going to be bagged up here it's not going anywhere
05:02sorry this is just like one of those
05:04it's really hard to get off
05:06that's fine take your time
05:08oh my god
05:32oh my god
05:38what are the green are those extensions clips or anything to take those out
05:58i can't take them out they're like in my like they're like in
06:02if you look at a flyer we can get them out
06:06what about that tie
06:10um
06:12i'm going to hold off and see what
06:14i know
06:16it's kind of weird
06:18i don't know
06:20for that
06:22alright mckenzie
06:26just hang out up against that wall
06:28to your right
06:30i
06:32i
06:34okay
06:36you
06:38it
06:40i
06:42we
06:44you
06:46we
06:48we
06:50we
06:52we
06:54we
06:56we
06:58I don't know.
07:28I gotta take her down.
07:51Oh, you're the one transporting?
07:53Yeah.
07:54Oh, okay.
07:55That clarifies being done.
07:56Cause we weren't really told.
07:58Yeah.
07:59He wants her to go right downtown.
08:01Okay.
08:02Cause we just had, he brought one back the other night.
08:07Well, he didn't, but ag robbery and they at least gave us a little bit more information
08:14saying that they were ready to take her.
08:15So I think he called them to verify that they were going to take her and they said yes
08:21with the charges.
08:22We didn't get that information cause I know Mace called us and told us a little bit,
08:27but not that cause there was some confusion cause of the age.
08:30Okay.
08:31Maybe it changed.
08:32I mean, she's 18 now, so.
08:34That's, that's the only holdup that we had is we weren't sure if she was going to County County
08:38or.
08:39Well, I think because at the time that I'll, I'll tell you more, but.
08:43Um, I don't know if you want to put her in a holding and.
08:46No.
08:47Yeah.
08:48Um, we'll hold up.
08:49All right.
08:50We'll do that now.
08:51I don't know.
08:52You're an adult.
08:53So as soon as we're done doing what we're doing, you'll be able to make fun.
09:06Yeah.
09:07We have to wait for the detective to come back so we can figure out.
09:09Just have a seat for us.
09:11She was a bright-eyed teenager with dreams of fashion and love.
09:18He was her boyfriend since high school.
09:20Together, they were inseparable until they weren't.
09:24On a quiet morning in Strongsville, Ohio, Mackenzie Schirrilla drove her car into a building
09:32at over 100 miles per hour, killing him and another friend instantly.
09:38But was it just an accident?
09:41Or was it calculated?
09:43The court called her a killer.
09:45Her family calls her a victim of medical mystery.
09:48The black box told one story.
09:51Her silence told another.
09:53This is the fatal case of Mackenzie Schirrilla.
09:57And the devastating question at its core.
10:00Did she commit murder behind the wheel?
10:03Welcome to The Dark Stories.
10:06This is the channel where we journey deep into the shadows of crime, tragedy and the human psyche.
10:13Today's case asks us to examine what happens when love turns toxic, when youth meets trauma
10:21and when justice isn't so black and white.
10:24We bring you the tragic and chilling case of Mackenzie Schirrilla.
10:29The teen whose car became a weapon and whose life may never be the same.
10:34It was early morning, around 5.30am, on July 31st, 2022.
10:41A 2018 Toyota Camry came hurtling down Progress Drive, a dead-end industrial road in Strongsville, Ohio.
10:51There were no traffic lights, no people.
10:55Just one brick warehouse at the end.
10:58Inside the car were three people.
11:00Mackenzie Schirrilla, 17 years old, in the driver's seat.
11:05Her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, 20.
11:09And in the back seat, their friend Davian Flanagan, just 19.
11:14According to the vehicle's black box, the car was moving at more than 100 miles per hour
11:21when it ploughed directly into the warehouse wall.
11:25There was no attempt to brake, no swerve, no hesitation.
11:30Russo and Flanagan died instantly.
11:33Mackenzie was found unconscious, not breathing and badly injured.
11:38It took 45 minutes for anyone to discover the crash.
11:43And when first responders finally arrived, they couldn't make sense of what they saw.
11:49To those who knew her, Mackenzie Schirrilla was like any suburban teen.
11:55A high school senior with an interest in fashion design.
11:59She posted TikToks.
12:01She vaped.
12:02She smoked weed.
12:04She had big dreams and a steady boyfriend in Dominic Russo.
12:08A local favourite known for his easy charm and big heart.
12:13Their romance started when Mackenzie was just 14.
12:17Dominic was older, more confident.
12:21They were together for nearly four years.
12:24To their friends, they looked like soulmates.
12:27But behind the Instagram photos and birthday dinners,
12:31there were signs of something darker.
12:35By late 2021, the couple was living together in one of the Russo family's homes.
12:42But according to Dominic's mother, Christine Russo, the relationship was unravelling.
12:48She described fighting, breakups, shouting matches and even threats.
12:54In the final months, Christine said Mackenzie became possessive and Dominic often looked worn down by it.
13:02One chilling moment, just weeks before the crash, was overheard during an argument.
13:08Mackenzie allegedly shouted,
13:11I'm going to wreck this car right now.
13:13Another time, video footage showed her trying to break into Dominic's home.
13:19Were these empty threats from a heartbroken teen?
13:23Or warning signs of what was to come?
13:26The night before the crash started out normal,
13:2910.15pm, Mackenzie, Dominic and Davian attended a graduation party.
13:3611pm.
13:38They left the party and went to a friend's house to hang out.
13:42There, some of them smoked marijuana and they listened to music.
13:47Then, as dawn approached.
13:495.30am.
13:51The trio left.
13:54And minutes later, Mackenzie's Camry flew down Progress Drive and collided with the warehouse.
14:01There were no skid marks.
14:03No sign of evasive action.
14:06When investigators arrived, what they initially thought was an accident soon turned into a homicide investigation.
14:15The key to the case was the black box, the car's event data recorder.
14:21According to forensic analyst Mark Sargent, the data revealed that
14:26the accelerator pedal was fully pressed in the final five seconds.
14:31There was no use of the brake.
14:33The car experienced a hard right steering movement and was shifted between neutral and drive in a strange pattern.
14:42There were no mechanical failures.
14:45The engine was working perfectly.
14:47So was the brake system.
14:50Mackenzie's fuzzy slipper was found wedged between the gas pedal and floor mat.
14:55But Sargent concluded it could not have caused unintended acceleration.
15:01The conclusion, someone, intentionally, floored the gas until impact.
15:08Mackenzie was also found to be under the influence of marijuana and had psilocybin mushrooms, a psychedelic, in her possession.
15:18But perhaps more damning was the trail of digital evidence.
15:22Detective Zaki Hazu uncovered over 100 examples of dangerous driving on Mackenzie's social media.
15:31Driving while high.
15:33Driving while recording TikToks.
15:36Speeding.
15:37Swerving through traffic.
15:39All of it painted the image of someone who treated driving recklessly, not seriously.
15:45The prosecution believed this history, combined with the fractured relationship, created a clear motive.
15:54The trial was held in August 2023.
15:58Mackenzie faced 12 charges, including two counts of murder, aggravated vehicular homicide, felonious assault and drug possession.
16:09Because it was a bench trial.
16:10Because it was a bench trial, there was no jury.
16:13Her fate was in the hands of Judge Nancy Margaret Russo.
16:17No relation to Dominic.
16:19The judge didn't mince words.
16:22She called Mackenzie, hell on wheels, and said, this was not reckless driving.
16:29This was a mission.
16:30And she executed it with precision.
16:33The decision was death.
16:35She was sentenced to two concurrent 15 years to life terms, with the possibility of parole after 15 years.
16:43Her driver's license was revoked for life.
16:47Mackenzie gave a tearful apology in court.
16:50To the families of Dom and Davian.
16:53I am so deeply sorry.
16:55I wish I could remember what happened.
16:58I'd never do this on purpose.
17:00I'm heartbroken.
17:02But Mackenzie's parents, Steve and Natalie Sherilla, say the court got it wrong.
17:09They believed the crash may have been caused by a medical event.
17:14Specifically, a loss of consciousness, backed by health data they claim was ignored in court.
17:21They also point to text messages from Dominic, apologizing and suggesting he may have been the aggressor in some of their fights.
17:30Steve Sherilla said, show me one piece of evidence that says she did this on purpose.
17:36There isn't any.
17:38There's no proof what really happened inside that car.
17:41Her new legal team has already filed appeals and post-conviction relief motions.
17:47But so far, the conviction has been upheld.
17:51Still, the fight continues.
17:54The heartbreak extends far beyond the courtroom.
17:58Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan, both young men full of potential, are gone.
18:05Forever.
18:06Dominic's sister said,
18:08I can't imagine how I'd feel if Mackenzie gets out in fourteen years.
18:13My brother doesn't come back in fifteen years.
18:16But Dominic's father, Frank Russo, surprised many with his compassion.
18:22I lost my son.
18:24It's unbearable.
18:25But she's a kid too.
18:27Her parents are destroyed.
18:29I wish there was a way she could get help.
18:32Some kind of treatment.
18:34I don't want her life completely ruined.
18:37It's a tragic irony.
18:39That even among grief, there's empathy.
18:43The case of Mackenzie Sherilla is full of contradictions.
18:47The law called it murder.
18:49Her parents call it a medical episode.
18:52The car's black box told a story of precision.
18:56Mackenzie says she remembers nothing.
18:58And somewhere between the facts and the feelings.
19:02Two families are shattered.
19:04And two boys are never coming home.
19:07Was this a crime of passion?
19:10A moment of madness?
19:12Or the final chapter of a toxic love story gone horribly wrong?
19:16No matter the verdict, this case leaves behind one haunting truth.
19:22Some tragedies have no easy answers.
19:25A moment of madness.
19:26Thank you for watching the dark stories.
19:28If you found this case haunting or compelling,
19:31please subscribe, like, and hit the notification bell
19:35to stay updated with more true crime deep dives.
19:39We tell the stories that others overlook.
19:42Because behind every crime, there's a darkness worth exploring.
19:46Until next time, stay safe, stay curious, and stay in the dark.
Be the first to comment
Add your comment

Recommended

1:36