Political analyst Courtney Donovan Smith explains how the Bluebird Protests led to the formation of civic groups that propelled Taiwan's mass recall movement.
00:00Talk about the origins of those civic groups and where they came from.
00:03Well, they came from, they started out from what was called the Bluebird Movement.
00:09And this is when thousands of people for many nights running came out in protest of the opposition-controlled legislature
00:18for several legislative moves that they made, including trying to expand the power of the legislative branch
00:25to take functions, for example, allotted to the judiciary and also to extend its power and influence more over the executive branch.
00:35So these rallies and this movement led to and joined with other civic groups.
00:43They started thinking about, well, what can we do about this?
00:47So they started forming these recall campaigns, and the first ones started getting off the ground in December.
00:54Now, there were some individual people, for example, Ke Jemming, who's the head of the DPP caucus.
01:02He came out in early January supporting the recall movements.
01:07But the party itself kept its distance.
01:11My suspicion is that they were concerned that this would look like they were trying to overturn democracy.
01:16And so the party was very slow to back these movements, very much in contrast to the KMT, but theirs were in response to these recalls.
01:28Now, eventually, as it became clear that they were picking up a lot of momentum,
01:35the DPP did start tacitly supporting them and then later on officially supporting them.
01:42But they have not taken leadership positions, but they've backed them logistically, such as ordering billboards and things like that.
01:50So why did none of the KMT campaigns to recall DPP lawmakers make it to the voting stage?
01:59Well, the momentum was definitely on the side of the recall campaigners who came out of a social movement.
02:05So when you came out of a social movement like the Bluebird movement, you've already got an organizational spirit.
02:11You have strong bonds between the people who've participated.
02:15And, you know, they already have this camaraderie.
02:18And so they went into it.
02:20They also started much earlier, which really helped.
02:24They were also backed by Robert Zowell, the founder of UMC.
02:28So they also had better resources.
02:30Now, the KMT, in response to these, started trying to launch their own.
02:36But they did not have that momentum.
02:38They did not have that cohesion.
02:40And you can't organize a campaign based on party members only.
02:45And so as they lost momentum, there were allegations that a lot of them were copying, for example, party membership role information and committing voter fraud by forging signatures.
02:57Now, not all of these people have been found guilty by any means, but there have been some confessions.
03:03So at least some cases were accurate.
03:07But none of them, but once, you know, once these investigations started, what volunteers they did have to help canvas for the signatures to meet the thresholds, they evaporated.
Be the first to comment