- 11 months ago
Julia Wallace's murder remains one of the most puzzling crimes, to have ever taken place. An enigma that continues to confound even the sharpest of minds.
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00This is the classic murder in that it's perfectly planned.
00:21Julia Wallace's murder remains one of the most puzzling crimes to have ever taken place,
00:27an enigma that continues to confound even the sharpest of minds.
00:31The mystery, with its strange twists and turns, has cemented itself as one of Britain's most
00:35notorious unsolved murders.
00:38It all began in the seemingly tranquil walls of the Wallace family home, where Julia Wallace
00:43met a brutal, unexpected end.
00:47Her husband, William Herbert Wallace, found himself at the heart of the investigation,
00:51first convicted of her murder, only to have the case fall apart.
00:56A real-world locked-room mystery, one that challenges logic and defies resolution.
01:02The Wallaces lived in a pretty basic house, two up, two down, but it had the inside bathroom
01:08and it was kept in very well-good order.
01:11They lived a fairly simple life, but they were content together, they liked to play
01:14music together, and William, there was nothing really to suggest that there was any violence
01:20in William whatsoever, or that the marriage was in any great difficulties.
01:24The year is 1931, and in the quiet, unassuming Wolverton Street in Anfield, William Herbert
01:30Wallace and his wife, Julia, lived together in a seemingly perfect marriage.
01:36To those on the outside, the couple appeared the epitome of domestic bliss.
01:40William, a man of impeccable reputation, worked for the Prudential Assurance Company, where
01:46his colleagues spoke of him with the utmost respect.
01:52Wallace worked for the Prudential, and he came to Liverpool in 1914 with his wife, Julia.
01:58He didn't have many friends, he was sort of a bit of a lonely sort of person, but he was
02:02avidly into chess, and he used to go down to the chess club in the city centre.
02:07He was also into music, Julia used to play the piano.
02:10So Wallace decided quite late in life to pick the violin up, and he used to, he was taught
02:16by his, he takes lessons off his Prudential boss, Joseph Crewe, who, you know, lived in
02:23the Menlove Gardens area.
02:24He also taught chemistry in the city centre.
02:27The house he lived in wasn't too bad, actually, you know, he had several bedrooms in it, and
02:32a bathroom inside, you know, when most bathrooms are outside.
02:36And he had his back room set up into a makeshift laboratory, where he'd, you know, do his chemistry
02:40tests and all that.
02:43But who was Wallace?
02:47I don't think we'll ever know properly.
02:50On the night of Monday the 19th of January, when Wallace arrived at Liverpool's Central
02:54Chess Club, a message was waiting for him.
02:58A man by the name R.M. Qualtrough had phoned to request Wallace to call at 25 Menlove Gardens
03:05East at 7.30pm the following evening to discuss insurance.
03:11The following night, Wallace set out on his mission, as a mysterious caller had instructed.
03:16He took the tram to Mossley Hill, arriving at Menlove Gardens West.
03:20As he walked around, Wallace soon realised the area had Menlove Gardens North, South
03:26and West, but no East.
03:29Wallace approached the nearest house at 25 Menlove Gardens West and knocked on the door,
03:33hoping for some clarification, but the occupant told him he was not at the right house.
03:38There was no Qualtrough here.
03:41He asked several passers-by in the neighbourhood for directions, but none could offer any assistance.
03:46Approaching a local policeman on his beat, enquiring about the mysterious address, but
03:50even the officer was unable to provide him with an answer.
03:54Wallace made enquiries in a nearby newsagent, hoping someone might know of this elusive
03:59Menlove Gardens East, but his efforts were equally fruitless.
04:03For almost 45 minutes, Wallace scoured the neighbourhood, but the address remained elusive.
04:10Little did Wallace know, this fruitless search would be the least of his troubles.
04:15The night was far from over, and the true horror was yet to unfold.
04:20Wallace got back to Wolverton Street at about quarter to nine, roughly about two hours since
04:25he'd left.
04:27When he was going past the back alleyway, his neighbours next door were coming out,
04:31the Johnstons, Florence and John Johnston.
04:35Mrs Johnston said, hello Mr Wallace, and Wallace just said to her, have you heard anything
04:40unusual?
04:41And they said, no, why?
04:42And he went, I've tried to get access to the house, I've gone to the front, gone to the
04:45back, to the front again, and I can't gain access, and they said, well, try again and
04:51we'll wait.
04:52So the Johnstons wait at the back of Wallace's backyard door.
04:55Wallace goes up to the back kitchen door and says, it opens now.
05:01He goes into the house, the Johnstons are outside and he can hear them going round the
05:05house calling Julie's name.
05:07Then about a minute and a half later, after them going in, he comes outside, anxious.
05:13He said, come in, she's been killed.
05:15So the three of them go into the front parlor, that's where the body's found.
05:20Wallace leaned over, and the body was lying there with the mackintosh tucked underneath,
05:27underneath the body.
05:29The Johnstons, Mrs. Johnston goes in the room.
05:33John Johnston just looks round the door and says, I'll go and get the police.
05:38So he goes for the police, and Wallace and Mrs. Johnston wait there.
05:43About ten past nine, the first policeman on the scene, Fred Williams, comes in.
05:51Then the CID are eventually called, and they all come out.
05:55If you look at it from the detective's point of view, who turned up on the scene, there'd
05:58be no forced entry into the property.
06:01He had made a point of making himself known in the Manlove Avenue area to make sure he
06:09had his alibi in it.
06:11I can see why the detectives started to think it could well be him here, but what they didn't
06:14have really was any motive.
06:18Did William Herbert Wallace in fact murder his wife?
06:22Well, the police seem to think so.
06:24Their theory relied on William's burnt, blood-soaked mackintosh, which had been found underneath
06:29a Julia's body.
06:31Officers surmised he had worn the coat as a shield to protect himself from blood splatter.
06:38So here stood in front of the former Anfield Road police station, which is where William
06:42Wallace was taken for questioning immediately after the body of his wife, Julia, was found
06:48on the 20th of January 1931, nearby in Wolverson Street.
06:53Pretty grimy and basic within the police station.
06:55A cell without any running water, kept in there for long, lengthy periods of time.
07:02But in reality, he was taken there really to give a statement.
07:04He wasn't necessarily under suspicion, or they certainly didn't tell him he was.
07:08It was a case of come in and give a voluntary interview, which you would call it nowadays,
07:13just to account for his movements on the night.
07:15So as much as we describe the cells as quite grim, and I've actually been in them in a
07:20previous life, I think it's fair to say he probably didn't actually go into one because
07:23he wasn't officially under caution at that time.
07:26But it would have been very basic, I think a room with a desk, a couple of policemen
07:31there, unless he was firing away questions at him.
07:35Certainly when you look at the reports into the crime, he was under suspicion from one
07:39of the officers immediately, due to his fairly ice-cold demeanour and lack of any real visible
07:45signs of obsession at the time.
07:48John McFall, the police surgeon.
07:50When he first examines Mrs Wallace's body, he says that it was probably two hours before
07:58that she'd been murdered.
08:00Now what happened is, when he's writing the statement, he comes to the conclusion that
08:06the murder occurred about four hours before, which would have been about six o'clock, which
08:12was impossible really, because the milk boy's seen her, and the milk boy delivered the milk
08:17at about twenty-five to seven.
08:19This is the classic murder, in that it's perfectly planned, either somebody has managed to get
08:27Wallace out of the house because they knew the only way to get in to Julia was to get
08:32him out, and he was a man of creature habits, you knew he might go to the chess club one
08:36night a week, to get him out on another night, it was quite difficult to do so.
08:40So you basically telephoned and said, come to this address in Walton, where the houses
08:45are big and grand, and Wallace is thinking in his head, this might be a good annuity
08:49for me, I'll get a good commission on this one.
08:53That's one way of looking at it.
08:54Another way of looking at it is if Wallace is guilty, he again has planned it to perfection
08:58and time-wise that he's done it, and he's rushed out.
09:03He's got the tram times worked out to perfection, and he's made sure he's got himself visible
09:09in as many different parts of that location of the city as he could do, to emphasise that
09:13he simply couldn't have done it because he wasn't there.
09:16One of the things as well is that there was confusions over the time of death, but one
09:19of the pathologists actually put the time of death as around 6.30pm, which was before
09:24he left the property.
09:26So they, detectives, came to the conclusion that he had actually killed Julia, gone out
09:31down to the south end of the city, to give himself that cast-iron alibi, and then returned.
09:37And that was really the turning point which led to him getting arrested about two to three
09:40weeks after the crime had been committed.
09:43He was arrested eventually at the home of his sister-in-law, where he'd been staying
09:48temporarily because of the house being a crime scene.
09:51And the police really, I think, having a look, looking at others, there was only really one
09:54other subject than Gordon Parry, whose girlfriend gave him an alibi, that he was at the pictures.
10:00The police really looked at the fact that he seemed to go out of his way to attract
10:03attention in the Menlove Avenue area and Green Lane area, by asking everybody where this
10:08address was in Menlove Gardens, each which didn't exist.
10:11Detectives hypothesised William placed the telephone call to the chess club himself from
10:17a payphone just 400 yards from his house, using a disguised voice.
10:21He then went to the chess club to receive this message, feigning cluelessness as the
10:25details of his message were relayed to him.
10:28Then the following night, Wallace lured Julia into the parlour with the pretense that he
10:33wanted her to set up the room for a musical evening before killing his wife in cold blood.
10:39After this, he put on his other coats, hid the murder weapon up his sleeve and left.
10:44On his return to their home, pretending to be unable to enter the house would have allowed
10:49Wallace to wait for a passer-by to bear witness to his discovery of Julia's body.
10:54Quite private.
10:55Although in his diaries he does give a lot of stuff away, and I remember reading Raymond
11:00Chandler, the famous detective who loved this case by the way, I remember him saying
11:06about when people write diaries, they write them almost to be published so other people
11:10see them, but he does say a lot of things in his diaries, Wallace, but he didn't seem
11:15the sort of person who would really encourage conversation, you know what I mean?
11:24And also he was, you know, into philosophy, big way, Marcus Aurelius was the Stoic Roman
11:30philosopher, he loved the writings of him.
11:34He was a member of the chess club, albeit not a very good player, you know, he liked
11:39to do it.
11:40To me it's inconceivable that someone like this could have done what they were accused
11:43of, but in the case of no other suspect, I suppose you can see why he ended up getting
11:49charged.
11:50In fact, we're all asking the same question, who killed Julie Wallace, and why?
12:05The trial of Wallace opened on Wednesday the 22nd of April 1931 in this fantastic building.
12:13It was a four-day trial, which was quite short for them, and there was a lot of nonsense
12:19about certain parts, about, you know, the timing of the body, the drop of blood on
12:24the toilet rim, a lot of hoo-ha was made about that, and it was never, ever going to determine
12:31who murdered Mrs Wallace.
12:34And after the four days, Wallace was found guilty, much to the shock of most in the courtroom,
12:42you know, an audible gasp could be heard when the floorman of the jury said guilty.
12:47It was obviously a very well-attended trial, you know, it caught the public imagination.
12:52The reality is if the appeal failed, it's unlikely it would have been commuted to life
12:55imprisonment because it appeared on the face of a cult premeditated murder of a family
13:00member.
13:01So, you know, you can't imagine what must have been going through his mind at the time.
13:05Eventually Wallace, you know, was took to Walton Prison, and his solicitors put an appeal
13:12in right away, and his appeal took place in London on May the 18th and 19th in the
13:19Royal Courts of Justice in London, where the verdict was overturned because the appeal
13:27judges said that the verdict couldn't be supported with regards to the evidence.
13:35And it did make legal history because of the first time that happened.
13:38Normally speaking, you just had to go with the jury's verdict, but on this occasion,
13:42the High Court judges felt that no reasonable jury could really have convicted on the evidence
13:46given.
13:47There are many, many theories having developed over the last century, and they really only
13:52boil down to two suspects.
13:54The first of which is William Herbert Wallace, the husband.
13:59When the police arrived at the crime scene, they would have been very keen to eliminate
14:04Wallace from the inquiry.
14:06Statistics show that if someone is bludgeoned to death in their house, that six times out
14:11of ten, it's going to be the spouse, and that normally means the husband.
14:15And when the police did get to the crime scene, and when they did lay eyes on Wallace himself,
14:22they found he had a very cool and aloof demeanour.
14:26He looked uncaring, cold.
14:29He sort of treated his wife more like a sort of mortuary exhibit.
14:33He was feeding the cat.
14:35Didn't seem right to the police.
14:38And also, the whole reason for the murder seemed to be an attempted robbery.
14:44When the police actually asked what had been robbed, Wallace got down a cash box.
14:49It was about six foot high on a bookcase, and he showed the money that had been taken.
14:56The theory was that the murder had occurred because of this robbery, yet who knew about
15:02the cash box?
15:03It was virtually hidden on the bookshelf.
15:06But what motive did William have?
15:08There's evidence Wallace was tight-fisted with the household coffers.
15:12In his own diary, he wrote about berating his wife for buying too many newspapers, and
15:17supposedly he would walk long distances just to save a little money on tram fares.
15:23Alongside this, investigators found a hidden pouch secured by a safety pin inside Julia's
15:28corset containing a small stash of money.
15:30This could suggest she'd done this to keep some of her money secret from William.
15:36With Julia's death, Wallace would gain a small life insurance payout as well as access
15:41to the money in Julia's own bank account.
15:43At the end of the day, the money was still in his name.
15:45I mean, he had about ÂŁ150 in savings, which was a huge sum at that time.
15:50They lived a comfortable existence.
15:52Liverpool was a fairly desperate city at the time because of the Great Depression.
15:57But there was signs of affluence certainly in the South End where he'd gone on the wild
16:03goose chase looking for Mr. Qualtrough.
16:04But I think, generally speaking, even if she might have been a little bit miserly or
16:10he might have been miserly and felt she spent too much money, he seems to have enough there
16:14anyway.
16:15And when it comes to her, I suppose what he could have just simply done is told her he
16:19earned a lot less than he did her.
16:20I think, you know, there was doubts really as to whether he actually had the strength
16:25to actually, you know, conduct such a brutal murder the way he did her.
16:29There were probably far easier ways to have killed Julia if he wanted to do so.
16:35But there really was no motive.
16:37Wallace claimed to know exactly who killed his wife.
16:39And you ask him that particular question, who knew about the cash box and who would
16:45Julia Wallace have admitted to the house?
16:49Wallace gives a few names, but there's clearly one person he really suspects, Richard Gordon
16:55Parry.
16:56Parry had worked for Wallace.
16:58He knew all his business arrangements and he also knew Julia.
17:03So now we have a second suspect, Parry.
17:08So obviously the police bring in Parry, they interview him, get him to do a statement.
17:14They then check that statement.
17:16And one thing comes out of that checking is that Parry lied about his alibi for the night
17:26of the call.
17:29Now that automatically is a red flag.
17:32Someone has lied to the police in a statement which they signed about a murder investigation.
17:40Rather than digging deeper, the police just left it.
17:43They never followed up.
17:46Richard Gordon Parry had worked alongside Wallace at the Prudential where he'd once
17:50been under his supervision, though he'd been fired after being caught stealing.
17:56Parry knew exactly where the cash box was kept, but even more telling was his understanding
18:02of the Prudential pay and schedule.
18:04Tuesday night was the golden opportunity, the night when the cash box would be at its
18:09fullest.
18:10This was the same night Julia was found dead.
18:14Parry admitted he knew of the cafe where Wallace's chess club met.
18:18It wasn't a coincidence.
18:19He'd frequented the city cafe himself as a member of the Mersey Amateur Dramatic Society.
18:25Parry rehearsed there, and in fact it was during these very rehearsals that he'd crossed
18:29paths with Wallace on more than one occasion.
18:32Although Parry had an alibi for the night of the murder, on the night of the phone call
18:36he claimed to be with his girlfriend Lily Lloyd and her mother, which proved to be false.
18:42In fact, William Herbert Wallace himself accused Parry.
18:47He did it privately, and in all but name, he did it in public as well.
18:52Parry said nothing.
18:53He was tight-lipped.
18:54In fact, he later said he promised his father he would never speak about the case.
19:01Why?
19:02Many, many years later, we're now talking 50 years later, Parry was implicated by the
19:09testimony of a garage attendant who phoned in to a radio station, and he claimed that
19:16on the night of the murder, Parry had driven his car into the garage to get it cleaned
19:22inside and out, and inside the car, according to the garage attendant, there was blood.
19:29This evidence, because it can happen so long after the event, is highly controversial,
19:35but if taken at face value, it does implicate Parry.
19:39Yes, and I think Wallace is guilty, just for the simple fact that I don't think anyone
19:44else done it.
19:45I mean, Parry, it's been proved now that he had alibis, and now I think we're hearing
19:53the alibis could have been fabricated, but Mrs. Brine, who we were staying with, who
19:58was with that night from half six to half eight, and her daughter, Savona, and her nephew,
20:04Harold, she's hardly gonna jeopardize them or herself by, you know, giving an alibi to
20:10a possible murderer, so really, it just leaves Wallace.
20:14This is just smoke, and once the smoke clears, all we're left with is William Herbert Wallace,
20:21the man the police suspected all along.
20:25Others will say, yeah, but there's no sort of smoke without a fire, is there?
20:31Parry had lied, he was implicated, he knew about the cash box, had inside knowledge,
20:37and he was evasive about the crime, about talking about the crime for the rest of his life.
20:42A more reliable plan would have been to send Wallace on his wild goose chase using a real
20:46name and address, even an actual address at Menlove Gardens would have bought an ample
20:52amount of time for a straightforward robbery.
20:55Did they fear Wallace would check a directory?
20:58Someone might have made the call, and someone else might have killed Julia Wallace.
21:02In other words, Parry could have been involved, but might have not been the killer.
21:09One theory has been developed over the last 20 years, it's called the accomplice theory,
21:14that suggests that the motive was not murder, but robbery, which Parry had instigated,
21:20and he worked with an accomplice who arrived at the house on the night of the murder,
21:25saying there was a mix-up at the Qualtrough call.
21:27In fact, she was Qualtrough, and he got let in by Julia.
21:32The plan?
21:32It was a distraction burglary.
21:34But unfortunately, he got caught out, and to silence Julia, he murdered her.
21:40For me, I think the thing that shows that he is innocent is that he's buried in the
21:44same grave as her, and I really don't think someone who was generally a good man with
21:50a conscience would actually kill his wife and then go and get buried with her, after
21:53his own death.
21:55While many believe that William Wallace was guilty and managed to escape justice, his
21:59own lawyers even were convinced of his guilt, there are others who are certain he was an
22:04innocent man trapped in a nightmare of circumstantial evidence.
22:10William Herbert Wallace, once a respected insurance agent, returned to his job at the
22:15Prudential, but the world around him had shifted.
22:18The court's decision to clear his name didn't erase the lingering doubt that had consumed
22:23the public.
22:24Many believed Wallace was guilty, convinced he'd somehow gotten away with murder.
22:30Former clients, once trusting, now turned their backs on him.
22:34Hate mail arrived, each letter a bitter reminder of the trial that had now defined his life.
22:40More than that, physical threats began.
22:43Wallace was forced to retreat from his former role.
22:46The once proud insurance man took up a clerical job at his employer's head office.
22:52On the 26th of February 1933, just shy of two years after his appeal, William Herbert
22:58Wallace succumbed to the very ailment that had haunted him throughout his life, kidney
23:03disease.
23:04Buried in Anfield Cemetery along with his wife, Wallace's story came to a quiet end.
23:09But the whispers, the doubt and the questions about his past would follow him to the grave.
23:16The question of who brutally killed Julia Wallace in her own home remains shrouded in
23:23speculation.
23:24This is a case that remains stone cold.
Comments