00:00He says that Hazrat Ali's son Muhammad bin Hanifiyah
00:03who is a woman named Hanifiyah
00:05whom Hazrat Ali married after the death of Sayyidah Fatima
00:08he was born to her
00:10He says that he used to praise Yazid ibn Muawiyah a lot
00:13Where is it written? In which hadith?
00:15No, his words are in the hadith
00:16He says that it is mentioned in Tafsir ibn Kaseer
00:18which in Arabic is known as Al-Bidayah wa An-Nahaya
00:20It is mentioned in that
00:21Yes, show it
00:22I can't show it to you
00:23I can't show it to you
00:24I can't show it to you
00:25Because in that, Muhammad bin Hanifiyah
00:28is accompanied by Abdullah bin Muti
00:32Muhammad bin Hanifiyah is a follower
00:35Abdullah bin Muti is the one
00:37whom Huzoor himself gave as a dowry
00:39He is among the junior companions
00:40Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam
00:42And he says to Muhammad bin Hanifiyah
00:44Why are you sitting quietly?
00:46Your brother Hussain has been killed
00:48because of this Yazid
00:50So stand against him
00:53So Muhammad bin Hanifiyah says
00:56and Abdullah bin Muti says
00:58that his deeds are such
01:00that a stone falls from the sky
01:02which are his bad deeds
01:04He says that he is a drunkard
01:06and he has the words of a drunkard in it
01:08and other words as well
01:09He says that where is it written?
01:11So Muhammad bin Hanifiyah says
01:14that as long as I stay with him
01:17I have not seen anything like this in him
01:21He says that he has found him
01:23to be a follower of Namaz
01:25and Sunnah
01:27The ones whose forefathers
01:29are going to break Sunnah
01:31He says that he has found him
01:33to be a follower of Sunnah
01:34So he says that Muhammad bin Hanifiyah
01:35has glorified him
01:36By the way, I have elaborated this
01:38Then the rest said
01:39Huzoor, as long as you are there
01:41you have found him to be like this
01:43That is, as long as he was there
01:45he was wearing a turban and offering Namaz
01:47Earlier he was not offering Namaz
01:50That is, he was wearing a turban
01:52So, as long as he was there
01:54he was wearing a turban and offering Namaz
01:56So, Abdullah bin Muti is a Sahabi
02:00and Muhammad bin Hanifiyah is a Tabi
02:02When the call of Sahabi and Tabi
02:03collides, then who will be believed?
02:05Sahabi
02:06Then the call of Muhammad bin Hanifiyah
02:07gets cancelled
02:09That is why Sheikh Zubair Ali Zahi
02:11has written in his book
02:13that if you believe this narration
02:15then you will have to believe
02:16that he was a drunkard
02:18Because we will follow the Sahabi
02:20and not follow the Tabi
02:22So, this narration also fits
02:24in their gaps
