00:00 Some congressmen and one of them recommended the original framers of the 1987 Constitution
00:06 to restrict the use of unlawful means unless otherwise provided by law
00:10 in the provision of the Constitution.
00:13 This is so that the economic provisions of the Constitution will not be restricted
00:17 but a former Supreme Court Justice took care of this.
00:21 Tina Panganiban Perez was able to stop this.
00:27 Former Supreme Court Justice Adolfo Ascuna was one of the pioneers of the 1987 Constitution
00:34 which according to him is the longest constitution that has not been amended.
00:39 The reason is the vast provision on how the Congress will vote on the Charter Change,
00:45 whether the Senate and the House of Representatives will be separated or only one.
00:49 According to Ascuna, in the original draft of the 1987 Constitution,
00:53 the form of the government is unicameral. In the discussions for its abolition,
00:59 it became bicameral, which is the current form of the Congress.
01:03 But he did not change the provision on the vote of the two courts.
01:08 Ascuna believes that the vote should be separated
01:11 just like the two courts do in the ordinary law.
01:15 As long as you have three-fourths vote in the Senate and three-fourths vote here,
01:20 there's no question it can be considered as a proposed amendment
01:25 and submitted to the common elect for a plebiscite.
01:29 And that will fulfill the requirement of the first three-fourths vote of all its members.
01:38 And if there's any question, then let someone bring it to the Supreme Court.
01:43 To amend the Constitution, the recommendation of former Supreme Court Justice Adolfo Ascuna
01:49 is to amend the provisions of the "unless otherwise provided by law."
01:55 This is also the position of some Congressmen.
01:58 It makes it changeable by legislation.
02:01 This is, to me, the best solution to the economic provisions restriction
02:08 because economic provisions should be flexible and they should not be cast in stone.
02:15 The purpose is to introduce flexibility.
02:19 We don't want to put a specific parameter.
02:22 But former Supreme Court Justice Reynato Puno is against this.
02:27 I raised a red flag on this way of amending the Constitution.
02:35 I suggested that we just repeal outright these three restrictive provisions
02:44 that will release the power of Congress to pass the necessary laws
02:50 in order to liberalize the so-called restrictive provisions.
02:57 Some Congressmen have already answered.
03:00 There will always be the possibility of a constitutional challenge.
03:04 So the question before us now as lawmakers,
03:07 will we continue this if we know that this will be a challenge?
03:11 Of course, at the end of the day, it will still go back to the plebiscite.
03:15 The target of the Camera is to finish the deliberation on RPH 7 next week
03:21 and to include it in the second reading from March 11 to March 13.
03:27 It is possible to include it in the third reading before the Congress holiday break on March 23.
03:33 However, the "unless otherwise approved by the Senate" will not be a problem.
03:39 This was first stated by the Senators that they will not hasten the deliberation
03:43 on the amendment of the economic provisions of the Constitution.
03:47 For GMA Integrated News, Tina Panganiban Perez, for Tutok, 24 hours.
03:55 [Music]