00:00 Namaste, our special guest today is special for you too.
00:06 Why? Because his talks and his things directly relate to you, your pocket and your future.
00:16 We have got the opportunity to talk to him because his book has been released, Breaking the Mold.
00:24 In which we are discussing such things, you are discussing, the writer of that book,
00:32 which is related to your future, our children, our youth and our parents.
00:40 The writers of the book are Raghuram Rajan ji and Rohit Lamba ji. Let's talk to them.
00:45 Welcome sir. Thank you.
00:49 The first question is, it is being discussed continuously that in the next one year, two years,
00:55 the economy will be of 5 trillion and by 2047, India will become a developed country.
01:02 What is the truth in this?
01:04 In one year, 5 trillion cannot be made.
01:07 If you do mathematics, the rate of production will be 6% to 14-15% in one year.
01:21 That cannot be. So these numbers, people sometimes spread like this, but they have no meaning.
01:30 If you say that we want to become a developed country in 2047, then we have to work, do homework.
01:41 The homework is how to increase the rate of production because 6% will not work.
01:48 If we work on 6% or even 7%, let's say we work on 7%, then it is very difficult to go to 7% for 24 years.
02:05 But if we do that, we will only reach $10,000 per capita income.
02:14 That is even lower than China in today's time.
02:19 So we have to increase the rate of production a lot if we want to reach South Korea or America's per capita income.
02:29 So what should we do to increase the rate of production?
02:33 So we write in this book, which is also translated into Hindi, that the most important thing is to increase our human capital.
02:49 How to increase it?
02:52 First, we have to focus on education. Second, we have to focus on health care.
03:02 And when we say education, we have to focus on every aspect.
03:07 So how to increase primary education?
03:12 Because students in 5th grade are not able to do 2nd grade math problems.
03:22 50% students are not able to do it.
03:25 So how to increase their learning?
03:28 Because if they cannot do 2nd grade math, then what will they do when they graduate?
03:36 Because in every job, these skills are needed.
03:41 So we make a plan in the book, how to strengthen all these things, education, health care, nutrition.
03:51 35% of children suffer from malnutrition.
03:58 How to increase their nutrition?
04:01 We have to do this in mission mode. Because if 35% children suffer from malnutrition, then in 20 years, 35% of the workforce...
04:17 There is a report by the Union Trust, which says that by 2050, around 35 crore people in India will be above the age of 60.
04:28 So our productivity will decrease.
04:33 That is why you are talking about a plan.
04:36 Yes, we are saying that we have to become rich, we have to become a prosperous country before we become an old country.
04:45 And the demographic dividend that you are talking about, will be reduced by 2050.
05:02 So we have to work a lot from today onwards. Because we have to give skills to every youth generation.
05:14 So that they get good jobs and we can become a prosperous country with that.
05:24 So we have to focus on them from today.
05:27 And we write in the book how to focus.
05:32 One question that comes up, you are saying that the path that we take is through education and health care.
05:39 How far will this path take us? Will it take us to the developed India?
05:46 We are saying that we have to follow this path if we think about manufacturing or services.
06:00 But there is a change in the environment.
06:06 Nowadays, we can reach straight to America or Europe by doing services.
06:14 Like in the pandemic, the consultant who was sitting in Denver was working for a Chicago firm.
06:30 Working at a distance.
06:33 So if you can work for a Chicago firm in Denver, why can't you work for a Chicago firm in Bangalore?
06:46 So nowadays, many firms are seeing that here they give 200,000 to 200,000 dollars to employ.
06:58 If we employ the same person in India, we will have to pay at most 40,000 dollars a year.
07:08 So they are coming here to find consultants, legal lawyers, doctors.
07:20 So they can work at a distance.
07:24 And many jobs are being created.
07:28 Like this Global Capability Center.
07:31 It is a center that is established here, like in Bangalore, Chennai, Jaipur.
07:40 And by working here, they sell their work there.
07:44 Like Goldman Sachs' biggest office.
07:47 Goldman Sachs is an American investment bank.
07:50 Its biggest office is outside New York, in Bangalore.
07:54 What do they do? They make trading models, risk management models for Goldman Sachs.
08:01 All these engineers and financial consultants are working in Bangalore.
08:06 So we can expand these types of jobs.
08:12 But what do we need for this?
08:15 We need to increase education.
08:20 Because people come here and see if they are IIT graduates, NIT graduates or IIM graduates.
08:26 But our graduates are very few from those institutions.
08:31 1000-2000 graduates.
08:35 We need 200,000 graduates.
08:38 Every year, there are 2.5 million engineering graduates from here.
08:45 But many graduates are not of high quality.
08:49 So we need to increase the quality.
08:51 So that everyone gets this job.
08:54 The world is coming here to find our engineers, our management graduates.
09:01 So we need to increase the quality so that they get jobs here.
09:07 When it comes to Raghuram Rajan,
09:11 Is there a perception that he is the one who criticizes the current government?
09:21 Or is he the one who will join Congress in the future?
09:27 Many people ask this question on social media, comments, digital.
09:33 I would like to hear your take on this.
09:36 I talk to every politician who wants to talk to me.
09:40 A few days ago, I spoke to Mr. Rewandt Reddy.
09:45 I spoke to Mr. Udhav Thackeray and Aditya Thackeray.
09:53 Because they have a vision.
09:56 I want to ask what is your vision for India?
10:00 And I learn something from that.
10:03 If there is a BJP politician who wants to talk, I will talk to him too.
10:09 It doesn't mean that I am going to join a party.
10:12 I am an academic.
10:14 And I want to think about what is the best path for India.
10:21 And how to strengthen it.
10:25 I am a consultant with DMK.
10:28 It doesn't mean that I am joining DMK tomorrow.
10:32 I want to work for India.
10:37 And if I don't talk to anyone about that work, I will never learn.
10:44 I talk to entrepreneurs, I talk to students.
10:48 When we talk, people make 2 and 2 make 50.
10:54 So it should be done.
10:57 So we are ending this talk with a very good line.
11:02 If the leaders of the BJP want to talk to Raghuram Rajan, he is open for that.
11:07 Today he has spoken and said that he wants to work for India.
11:12 These things are mentioned in his book.
11:15 Breaking the mold is his book.
11:17 Hindi translation is also available.
11:19 In Tamil and other languages, the translation of the book will be available.
11:22 It won't be that the book is in English and some other terminology.
11:29 You have said this in today's session and in other places.
11:32 This book is less about economics, more about India's future and people.
11:37 It is written in simple English.
11:40 One question is that the freebies are being given by the taxpayers.
11:46 And the taxpayers don't seem happy with this.
11:49 What is the reality of this? Is the gap increasing between the rich and the poor?
11:54 Will they feel that they have given away their money and distributed it to people for free?
11:59 There are two types of tax.
12:02 One is direct tax and the other is indirect tax.
12:04 Direct tax is the one that is deducted from our salary.
12:07 Indirect tax is like GST.
12:10 Like you buy a product or go to a restaurant, you have to pay a tax on it.
12:14 One fact that we keep in mind is that this is a big failure.
12:21 Historically, the middle class is paying taxes but because they are not seeing the benefits.
12:33 There is a famous phrase by Albert Hirschman, who says that the state's system is exiting it.
12:42 What does it mean to exit?
12:44 If I come from a middle class family, my parents are paying taxes but they are not seeing anything.
12:51 They are not sending their children to government schools or hospitals.
12:56 This creates a catch-22 situation.
13:00 Because as long as the middle class does not pay these services, it is very difficult to improve those services.
13:11 This is seen all over the world.
13:13 So, what we say in the book is that services for the poor is poor service.
13:16 If only the poor are going, because they are not paying the taxes properly, it becomes difficult to improve the services.
13:26 We get stuck in a vicious cycle.
13:28 The middle class thinks why should I pay taxes?
13:31 So, they try harder not to pay taxes.
13:34 They use all techniques.
13:36 We have written in the book that in many countries, it is considered a bad thing to sit for tea and say that I have not paid taxes.
13:48 This is considered a bad thing.
13:50 In India, to some extent, it is considered a skill.
13:53 How you paid taxes.
13:55 So, this cycle can break like this.
14:00 When the middle class sees that if they go to a government hospital, they get good treatment.
14:06 They will also feel that their tax is being used well.
14:09 If I go to an educational institute, I want to send my child there.
14:14 Like what is happening in Delhi, the condition of the central school is very good.
14:18 Government schools, the results of the children are almost government.
14:22 So, this should be India wide.
14:26 Secondly, as you said, in indirect taxes, we have implemented a system, GST.
14:35 It is a good system.
14:36 There are some shortcomings in it.
14:38 We should iron out them.
14:39 We should simplify it as much as possible.
14:42 We should make the tax system easy for producers, consumers, everyone.
14:46 Secondly, the system in which the central state is sharing taxes, it should be a little more solid.
14:54 The question arises again and again that in those states where the central and state governments are different.
15:00 There is no same party government.
15:02 There, the taxes of state governments are not able to come in that way.
15:06 It is stopped.
15:07 Again, this is not a problem of this government.
15:11 This is an institutional, what legacy are you leaving?
15:14 If the government changes tomorrow, should we go ahead with this evidence that if it is my government, I will release taxes.
15:21 If it is not my government, this is a dangerous precedent.
15:24 The courts should take notice of this.
15:27 And GST council should be made a little more autonomous.
15:29 It should be seamless here.
15:31 So much tax has been collected from Andhra Pradesh or Telangana.
15:36 Whether it is my government or not, if so much tax is coming from Hyderabad and this is the formula, then it should automatically go to that government.
Be the first to comment