American Idol fans are up in arms after fan favorite Pia Toscano was voted off the show. Reports say people are petitioning the show to bring Pia back and boot off Stefano, who was chosen to stay. Idol's voting system is under suspicion. Some people reported having trouble voting for Pia online. Glitches aside, Idol might be biased against women, as the teen girl fans often favor male contestants. The new judges are facing criticism too. They burned their one 'save' on Casey Abrams. Things will be okay for Pia, though, considering she's already landed a record deal. Besides, where are some of the Idol "winners" now?